Dignity Denied: The Case for Reform at State Veterans Homes

VA Budget and ModernizationHouse Veterans' Affairs Subcommittee on Health · 2025-04-29 · 119th Congress
The House Veterans' Affairs Subcommittee on Health held this oversight hearing to examine how the VA funds and monitors state veterans homes, which provide the largest share of federal long-term nursing care for veterans, following a 2022 GAO report on oversight gaps and a fatal COVID-19 outbreak at a Massachusetts veterans home. Begins at 0:26:11
Transcript
Highlights

Title

VA oversight and funding gaps at state veterans homes

Purpose

The House Veterans' Affairs Subcommittee on Health held this oversight hearing to examine how the VA funds and monitors state veterans homes, which provide the largest share of federal long-term nursing care for veterans, following a 2022 GAO report on oversight gaps and a fatal COVID-19 outbreak at a Massachusetts veterans home. Witnesses from GAO, the VA's Office of Geriatrics and Extended Care, the National Association of State Veterans Homes, and Louisiana's Department of Veterans Affairs testified on enforcement authority, medication reimbursement, construction grant backlogs, and elder suicide prevention. Begins at0:26:11

Who spoke

Chairwoman Mariannette Miller-Meeks (R-IA)0:26:11: Opened by citing a recent veteran suicide at a VA medical campus0:27:31 and described her bill to reimburse state veterans homes for high-cost medications0:30:13, plus concerns about restrictive construction-grant conditions0:30:41.

Ranking Member Julia Brownley (D-CA)0:31:10: Said state veterans homes serve 43% of VA-funded nursing home residents but receive only 18% of VA payments, with basic per diem covering under 30% of actual cost0:32:29; warned that proposed $880 billion in Medicaid cuts under reconciliation could push more veterans onto state homes0:33:34; pressed witnesses repeatedly on Medicaid-cut impact analysis0:46:291:27:12.

Dr. Scottie Hartronft, VA Executive Director, Geriatrics and Extended Care0:38:55: Described VA's survey process mirroring CMS standards0:38:55, $4.7 million in FY25 nursing-staff retention grants to 47 homes0:39:49, and reimbursement up to 65% of construction costs0:40:13; said his office is "adequately staffed"0:53:22 and that VA has restarted internal discussions on financial penalty authority0:49:10.

Sharon Silas, GAO Director of Health Care0:40:40: Reported roughly 15,000 veterans in 153 state veterans homes costing $1.5 billion in FY2023 at $265/day0:41:37; found 766 deficiencies with 40% repeated between 2019–2021 and 21% past corrective-action deadlines0:43:50; said VA's only enforcement tool is withholding per diem payments, which officials could not recall ever using0:43:50, and recommended a CMS-like range of penalties including civil fines0:44:44.

Rep. Sheila Cherfilus-McCormick (D-FL)0:51:59: Argued state veterans homes' per diem costs are one-third less than private nursing homes and nearly 90% less than VA community living centers0:52:28; pressed Hartronft on staffing and consistency of deficiencies0:53:221:00:59 and noted an anticipated cut of 72,000 (VA positions)0:56:24.

Rep. K. (Dr. Conaway) — a committee member0:57:17: Described the New Jersey veterans homes lawsuit resulting in $53 million in settlements to 119 families0:57:42; asked whether VA conducted in-person pandemic response reviews at affected homes0:58:32 and whether VA needs legislative authority to enforce standards1:00:59.

Rep. Dave Taylor (R-OH)1:02:59: Described an 80-plus-project construction grant backlog with waits of 5–10 years1:03:30; introduced the Veterans First Act to redirect USAID-identified wasteful spending toward the state veterans home construction backlog1:05:55.

Ed Harries, President, National Association of State Veterans Homes1:12:42: Said state homes provide about half of VA-supported skilled nursing care on 18% of the budget, with per diem of $262 vs. $424 for private homes and $1,971 for VA CLCs1:13:12; cited 70% four/five-star ratings vs. 35% for community homes1:13:39; said VA opposed the Providing Veterans Essential Medications Act despite acknowledging the problem1:15:46; called for at least $650 million in appropriations for pending construction projects1:16:38.

Colonel Charlton Meginley, Secretary, Louisiana Department of Veterans Affairs1:12:42: Reported VA-surveyed deficiencies at Louisiana's five homes fell 36% from 53 to 34 between 2023–2024, with 91% minimal severity1:20:27; said pressure ulcer rates run about one-third the national average1:21:21; said Louisiana turns away 72% of veterans with mental health needs due to capacity limits1:39:55.

Dr. Morrison — a committee member1:34:56: Emphasized the importance of data-driven oversight and asked witnesses how VA-state partnerships and data collection improve care quality1:36:591:39:30.

Key moments

Silas: 40% of state veterans homes were cited for the same deficiency in both 2019 and 2021, and 21% of corrective action plans were past due; VA officials could not recall ever withholding a per diem payment as an enforcement tool0:43:50.

Brownley: proposed federal Medicaid cuts of $880 billion over 10 years, mostly from Medicaid, which funds long-term care for more than 60% of nursing home residents0:33:34.

Harries: VA per diem is $262 for state homes vs. $424 for private community homes and $1,971 for VA community living centers, yet state homes provide about half of VA-supported skilled nursing care1:13:12.

Cherfilus-McCormick challenged Hartronft on whether "adequately staffed" claims were consistent with persistent deficiencies documented by GAO; Hartronft attributed increases partly to industrywide trends and centralization improving follow-through0:53:220:55:07.

Meginley: Louisiana turns away 72% of veterans with mental health needs due to lack of capacity, despite otherwise strong quality metrics1:39:55.

Taylor introduced the Veterans First Act to reallocate $2 billion in USAID funding to clear the state veterans home construction grant backlog; Brownley opposed it, calling it "a false choice" between veteran programs and foreign assistance/national security1:23:451:25:34.

Harries said NASVA was "surprised and disappointed" that VA testified in opposition to the Providing Veterans Essential Medications Act despite VA acknowledging the underlying problem in past conversations1:15:46.

Meginley cited a specific New Jersey settlement of $53 million across 119 families related to COVID-era deaths at two state veterans homes, with the state paying 60%0:57:42.

Hartronft said VA has "restarted discussions internally" on seeking authority for civil penalties or partial per diem withholding but remains in a "concurrence and discussion phase"0:49:101:00:23.

Harries noted the current interpretation of federal regulations bars a state veterans home from applying for a construction grant to start a new adult daycare program, only to expand or replace an existing one1:32:07.

Metadata

CommitteeHouse Veterans' Affairs Subcommittee on Health
Chamber / CongressHouse · 119th Congress
Date2025-04-29
TypeHearing
Witnesses
Mr. Ed Harries — President, National Association of State Veterans Homes
Ms. Sharon Silas — Director, Health Care, U.S. Government Accountability Office
Colonel Charlton Meginley — Secretary, Louisiana Department of Veterans Affairs
Dr. Scottie Hartronft — Executive Director, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs
Videoyoutube
Transcript176 caption blocks · 12,479 words · 1:43:44 runtime
EventCongress.gov 118153