Enhancing Educational Outcomes in Indian Country: Postsecondary Education at the Bureau of Indian Education

Tribal Programs and FundingHouse Natural Resources · 2025-06-24 · 119th Congress
The House Natural Resources Subcommittee on Oversight and the Education and Workforce Subcommittee on Higher Education and Workforce Development held a joint hearing to examine the Bureau of Indian Education's (BIE) management of its two postsecondary schools, Haskell Indian Nations University and the Southwestern Indian Polytechnic Institute (SIPI). Begins at 0:10:16
Transcript
Highlights

Title

Oversight of Haskell and SIPI amid mismanagement and proposed 90% budget cut

Purpose

The House Natural Resources Subcommittee on Oversight and the Education and Workforce Subcommittee on Higher Education and Workforce Development held a joint hearing to examine the Bureau of Indian Education's (BIE) management of its two postsecondary schools, Haskell Indian Nations University and the Southwestern Indian Polytechnic Institute (SIPI). Members reviewed a pattern of leadership turnover, deferred maintenance, low graduation rates, and a May 2025 Inspector General report on sexual harassment of Haskell women's basketball athletes, while also questioning the Trump administration's proposed budget, which would cut BIE postsecondary programs by nearly 90% and education construction funding by 80%. Witness Scott Davis, senior advisor exercising the delegated authority of the Assistant Secretary–Indian Affairs and a Haskell alumnus, testified on the department's plans. Begins at0:10:16

Who spoke

Chairman Paul Gosar (R-AZ)0:11:13: Opened by citing Haskell's failed background checks, a former Board of Regents member convicted of felonies0:13:08, a 27-of-36-buildings-in-severe-condition maintenance assessment0:14:23, and the May 2025 IG report on sexual harassment0:15:20; later questioned Davis on sovereignty, treaty obligations, and pressed him to "dream" about Haskell's future2:07:48.

Ranking Member Maxine Dexter (D-OR)0:16:36: Said Haskell faces a $90 million maintenance backlog driven by chronic underfunding0:18:02, warned the administration's budget cuts BIE construction 80% and postsecondary programs 90%0:18:26, and urged reauthorization of the Great American Outdoors Act (GAOA) to keep schools eligible for funding0:20:12.

Subcommittee Chairman Burgess Owens (R-UT)0:21:34: Cited a 2018 IG finding that neither BIE nor SIPI had a policy against faculty-student sexual relationships0:23:29 and called for solutions from Davis's testimony0:23:53.

Ranking Member Alma Adams (D-NC)0:23:53: Noted the FY26 budget request cuts BIE postsecondary funding by almost 90%0:28:21 and described February DOGE firings that had to be reversed0:27:57.

Chairman Tim Walberg (R-MI)0:29:37: Highlighted the IG report on basketball-team harassment and supervisors' failure to report it0:30:58.

Ranking Member Jared Huffman (D-CA)0:32:15: Attributed Haskell's problems mainly to loss of funding, citing the proposed 90% and 80% cuts0:33:08, and described DOGE firing nearly 25% of Haskell/SIPI staff in February, leading to garbage-filled dorms and undrinkable water0:34:32.

Chairman Bruce Westerman (R-AR)0:35:58: Said the prior administration stonewalled a bipartisan request for a 2022 BIE report0:36:49 and cited the banished former Regents member0:37:15.

Scott Davis, Senior Advisor exercising delegated authority of the Assistant Secretary–Indian Affairs0:40:10: A Haskell alumnus and 1988 All-American marathoner, he said his office is implementing background-check and harassment policies "as we speak"0:48:25, described the FY26 BIE budget request as roughly $22 million for Haskell/SIPI operations0:51:04, repeatedly said cuts were "nothing new" and pledged to pursue alternative/private/state funding and foundations0:52:23, and said he could not confirm whether a 90% cut was unprecedented or which colleges might close1:40:391:41:28.

Rep. Burgess Owens (R-UT)0:45:36: Asked Davis about the harassment findings and any Kansas state referral on athletic-trainer licensing0:47:56.

Rep. Maxine Dexter (D-OR)0:49:44: Asked whether the president's budget reflects the administration caring about tribal students0:50:09 and whether current infrastructure fosters a quality academic environment0:53:13.

Chairman Bruce Westerman (R-AR)0:54:57: Asked Davis to commit to working with Congress0:54:57 and about the greatest threats to students, citing uncertainty over pending legislation0:55:46.

Rep. Don Sam (Sanchez?), CA member1:01:04: Asked about BIE's role in accreditation oversight1:01:18 and cultural competency of staff1:02:32.

Rep. Glenn Grothman (R-WI)1:06:20: Asked about common majors at Haskell, enrollment growth of over 30%, and graduation rates estimated at 60–80%1:06:471:11:131:11:43.

Rep. Pablo Hernandez (D-PR)1:12:30: Asked how the department will enhance cultural continuity and community engagement at tribal colleges1:13:021:15:59.

Rep. Mike Collins (R-GA)1:18:34: Asked why no policy existed against faculty-student relationships and about background-check implementation progress1:20:121:21:29.

Ranking Member Adams (D-NC/Education) [1:22:29 second round noted separately below]: (see above)

Rep. Tracey Mann (R-KS)1:28:09: Noted Haskell is in his district, described his and Sen. Jerry Moran's bill to transfer Haskell governance to an independent Board of Trustees1:31:36, and asked whether BIE can realistically manage postsecondary education1:29:48.

Rep. James Moylan (R-GU)1:32:57: Asked about changes made after the IG report and oversight of the incoming interim president, Mackie Moore1:33:261:35:38.

Rep. Derek Tran (D-CA)1:37:32: Pressed Davis repeatedly on whether the 90% cut is unprecedented and which colleges might close, entering an article on the proposed cuts into the record1:38:541:40:10.

Rep. Troy Downing (R-MT)1:43:15: Asked about campus security, financial transparency measures, and why Haskell/SIPI have not received Great American Outdoors Act Legacy Restoration Fund projects1:46:51.

Rep. Emily Randall (D-WA)1:48:10: Asked whether Davis can meet commitments to Haskell while facing a 90% cut and what message that sends to prospective native students1:49:011:52:18.

Rep. Randy Fine (R-FL)1:54:07: Asked why the prior administration didn't act on known problems1:54:52 and floated giving students scholarships to attend any university instead of funding Haskell/SIPI directly1:56:32.

Ranking Member Dexter (second round)1:59:07: Asked what alternative funding tools exist beyond Davis's prior suggestions and whether school choice/voucher-like options are being considered2:01:04.

Rep. Alma Adams (second round, D-NC)2:02:53: Noted TCUs received $367.3 million under the Biden administration and that 30% of TCU students face food insecurity2:03:182:03:47.

Rep. Yassamin Ansari (D-AZ)2:14:48: Cited BIE serving roughly 46,000 students at 183 schools nationwide2:15:13, asked whether the federal trust obligation to Haskell/SIPI would continue if they left BIE or faced 90% cuts2:16:34, and said she would submit language requiring adequate funding tied to trust responsibility2:18:27.

Key moments

Gosar detailed that a 2023 facility assessment found 27 of Haskell's 36 buildings in severe condition needing immediate replacement, and that Haskell turned away newly enrolled students in fall 2024 for lack of housing0:14:23.

Dexter and multiple members repeatedly cited the administration's proposed 90% cut to BIE postsecondary programs and 80% cut to education construction funding as the central threat to both schools0:18:260:33:08.

Rep. Derek Tran pressed Davis three times on whether a 90% cut was unprecedented; Davis ultimately answered "I'm not certain" and could not say whether any tribal colleges would survive it1:40:391:41:28.

The May 5, 2025 DOI Inspector General report found a BIE employee sexually harassed Haskell women's basketball players, that supervisors knew and failed to report it, and that the same employee had been investigated for similar conduct roughly a decade earlier without consequence0:15:200:37:53.

Rep. Tracey Mann described his bill with Sen. Jerry Moran to transfer Haskell's governance from BIE to an independent Board of Trustees nominated by tribal communities while retaining federal support1:31:36.

Huffman said DOGE cuts removed nearly 25% of Haskell/SIPI staff in February, causing overrun dorm trash, undrinkable brown water, and failed dining service before some staff were rehired [0:34:32, 1:35:01 reference].

Rep. Randy Fine proposed giving the roughly 700 Haskell students scholarships to attend any U.S. college instead of funding the institution directly, given per-student costs he calculated near $31,000/year1:56:081:56:32.

Davis said Haskell's tuition is roughly $1,600–$1,700 per year and estimated graduation rates at 60–80% for students who start and finish, though he lacked precise data1:10:431:11:43.

Downing noted Haskell/SIPI have never received Great American Outdoors Act Legacy Restoration Fund projects despite eligibility, and Davis said he did not know why and questioned how the "Outdoors" act applies to colleges1:47:18.

Rep. Adams noted TCUs received $367.3 million in added funding under the Biden administration and that 30% of TCU students report food insecurity, pushing back on characterizations that the prior administration did nothing2:03:182:03:47.

Metadata

CommitteeHouse Natural Resources
Chamber / CongressHouse · 119th Congress
Date2025-06-24
TypeHearing
Witnesses
Mr. Scott Davis — Senior Advisor to the Secretary, Exercising the Delegated Authority of the Assistant Secretary- Indian Affairs, Department of the Interior
Videoyoutube
Transcript308 caption blocks · 23,391 words · 2:25:50 runtime
EventCongress.gov 118415