A Review of the U.S. Grain Standards Act

Farm Economy and USDA OversightHouse Agriculture Subcommittee on General Farm Commodities, Risk Management, and Credit · 2025-06-26 · 119th Congress
The House Agriculture Subcommittee on General Farm Commodities, Risk Management, and Credit held this hearing to examine reauthorization of the U.S. Begins at 0:10:19
Transcript
Highlights

Title

Reauthorizing the U.S. Grain Standards Act

Purpose

The House Agriculture Subcommittee on General Farm Commodities, Risk Management, and Credit held this hearing to examine reauthorization of the U.S. Grain Standards Act, several provisions of which expire September 30, 2025. Members heard from grain industry, inspection agency, farmer, and academic witnesses on modernizing grain-grading technology, emergency waiver authority, and the funding structure of the Federal Grain Inspection Service (FGIS). Begins at0:10:19

Who spoke

Chairman Scott (R-?)0:10:19: Opened by explaining the 1916 origins of the Grain Standards Act and warned a lapse in expiring provisions could disrupt grain inspection0:11:06; later asked Fryant about the FGIS realignment under AMS0:37:47 and Fryant about waiver process shortcomings1:20:37.

Ranking Member Davids (D-KS)0:12:05: Highlighted Kansas's $5.2 billion in 2023 ag exports and Kansas State's grain science program0:41:15; questioned Donley on the International Grains Program's global reach0:42:29 and Mikesh on technology funding partnerships0:44:22; gave closing statement1:50:49.

Ranking Member Craig (D-MN)0:13:57: Noted grain covers 40% of her district and stressed the need for an operationally efficient, well-funded FGIS amid trade tensions0:14:24.

Mr. Nicholas Fryant, Cargill/NGFA0:17:48: Urged Congress to invest in grain grading technology0:18:47 and strengthen emergency waiver authority for service disruptions0:20:50; described a 2015 provision requiring transparency during service withdrawals0:20:50 and an NGFA technology summit hosted at Cargill's Minneapolis offices0:50:09.

Mrs. Kia Mikesh, AAGIWA President0:23:10: Said state/private agencies conduct nine times as many inspections as FGIS before export0:24:07; warned the system is "the bottleneck" due to reliance on a shrinking pool of human inspectors0:26:01; described the daily life of an inspector, including 2 a.m. call-outs for shuttle trains1:33:00; said technology could cut a 4-person crew to 3 or fewer1:35:08.

Mr. Dave Walton, American Soybean Association0:28:01: Said soybeans are the top U.S. ag export at $31.2 billion/year1:04:30; described the 2023 removal of "soybeans of other color" (SPOC) as a grade factor after FGIS found no protein/oil impact0:31:02; warned reauthorization lapses during harvest would be "untimely"1:12:05.

Dr. Kevin Donley, Kansas State University0:32:47: Explained K-State's grain science curricula and the International Grains Program, which hosted 814 participants from 44 countries in 20240:43:14; suggested imaging technology could ease workforce shortages in grain inspection0:36:48.

Rep. Finstad (R-MN)0:57:27: Cited a $65 billion U.S. grain and oilseed trade surplus1:00:43 and asked Fryant about export challenges and reauthorization timing1:01:12.

Rep. Bazinski/gentle lady from Illinois1:02:36: Asked panelists about the most important legislative change needed, drawing responses on technology and user fees1:03:031:15:53.

Rep. Miller (R-IL)1:37:55: Noted Illinois exports 44% of its grain and asked Walton about system performance and foreign-material contamination penalties at ports1:41:50.

Rep. LaMalfa (R-CA)1:42:47: A rice grower, asked about the FGIS move to AMS and compared grain grading technology needs to other commodity grading programs1:43:45; asked Fryant why "blackbox" grading technology has taken 20 years to develop1:46:11.

Chairman Thompson (full committee, "the big chair")1:16:51: Said an authorization lapse would cost the farm economy $70 million a day and cited $26 billion in 2024 U.S. grain exports1:17:46; asked Donley about land-grant universities' role in grain technology R&D1:18:57.

Rep. Rose (R-TN)1:21:49: Asked Walton about FGIS's global "gold standard" prestige1:22:19 and Mikesh about official agencies' authority to conduct research1:23:46.

Rep. De La Cruz (R-TX)1:27:55: Pressed Mikesh on whether quantifiable error-rate data exists comparing human inspectors to new technology, and learned no such study is yet complete1:30:19.

A freshman committee member from North Carolina1:32:01: Asked Mikesh to describe a grain inspector's typical workday and cost savings from technology1:32:311:34:46, and asked Fryant about user fee predictability1:36:26.

Key moments

Chairman Thompson said a lapse in reauthorization would cost the farm economy more than $70 million a day, with nearly $100 million in corn and barley exported from Pennsylvania annually and $26 billion in U.S. grain exports in 20241:17:46.

Rep. Finstad cited a $65 billion U.S. trade surplus in grains and oilseeds1:00:43.

Walton described the 2023 removal of "soybeans of other color" (SPOC) as an official grading factor after FGIS testing found no significant protein or oil differences, resolving a penalty problem caused by a new soybean seed variety0:31:020:31:31.

Mikesh disclosed that no quantifiable comparison yet exists between human-inspector error rates and new imaging technology, saying such a study's timeline depends on what the subcommittee passes1:30:381:31:31.

Fryant said Cargill has spent roughly 20 years working on "blackbox" visual-imaging grading technology without full deployment, illustrating the difficulty of validating new tools1:46:11.

Mikesh said train sizes have grown from about 50 cars to 114-car trains loaded in under 5 hours, using the same personnel and standards as decades ago, straining inspection capacity1:09:19.

Walton warned that any disruption from a lapsed authorization would directly lower the price he receives at the elevator and disrupt the supply chain to foreign customers0:40:23.

Mikesh explained a near-monopoly problem: official agencies and FGIS hold most of the grading expertise and data needed to build inspection technology, but lack R&D funding tools, prompting calls for "other transactions authority"0:26:321:24:12.

Fryant said the 2015 reauthorization's waiver-related transparency requirements have worked better since, but urged Congress to more clearly define "emergency" in the statute1:20:581:21:22.

Donley noted the National Grain Center's Board of Appeals in Kansas City functions as "the Supreme Court of grain grading," resolving disputes using retained reference samples1:49:37.

Metadata

CommitteeHouse Agriculture Subcommittee on General Farm Commodities, Risk Management, and Credit
Chamber / CongressHouse · 119th Congress
Date2025-06-26
TypeHearing
Witnesses
Mr. Nicholas Friant — Director, Raw Material Quality & Regulaory, Cargill
Mrs. Kia Mikesh — President, American Association of Grain Inspection and Weighing Agencies
Mr. Dave Walton — Secretary, American Soybean Association
Dr. Kevin Donnelly — Professor Emeritus, Agronomy, Kansas State University
Videoyoutube
Transcript233 caption blocks · 16,521 words · 1:52:08 runtime
EventCongress.gov 118427