Highway Safety Under Threat: Examining Non-Domiciled CDL Issuance to Illegal Aliens

Immigration Enforcement and Sanctuary PoliciesHomeland Security Subcommittee on Oversight, Investigations, and Accountability · March 4, 2026 · 119th Congress
The House Homeland Security Subcommittee on Oversight, Investigations, and Accountability held this hearing on non-domiciled commercial driver's licenses (CDLs) issued to individuals unlawfully present in the United States, examining state compliance failures, federal enforcement coordination with ICE, and several fatal crashes involving non-domiciled CDL holders. Begins at ▶ 0:06:02
Transcript
Highlights

Title

Oversight hearing on non-domiciled CDLs issued to unauthorized immigrants

Purpose

The House Homeland Security Subcommittee on Oversight, Investigations, and Accountability held this hearing on non-domiciled commercial driver's licenses (CDLs) issued to individuals unlawfully present in the United States, examining state compliance failures, federal enforcement coordination with ICE, and several fatal crashes involving non-domiciled CDL holders. The session opened with a parliamentary dispute over the committee's jurisdiction before the chair and ranking member delivered opening statements, followed by testimony from officials in Oklahoma and Florida and an attorney representing petitioners challenging a new Department of Transportation rule. Begins at▶ 0:06:02

Who spoke

• Subcommittee Chairman▶ 0:00:18: Gaveled in the hearing on non-domiciled CDL issuance to unlawfully present individuals▶ 0:00:18, defended the committee's jurisdiction under Homeland Security's immigration-enforcement role▶ 0:01:47, cited DOT audit findings — 1 in 5 non-domicile CDLs failing standards in Illinois, 17,000 illegally issued in California, and over 50% non-compliant in New York▶ 0:07:03▶ 0:07:32 — and described the St. Lucie County and Delila Coleman crashes▶ 0:08:00▶ 0:08:59.

• Ranking Member▶ 0:00:48: Raised a parliamentary inquiry questioning whether the hearing's subject fell within the committee's jurisdiction rather than that of the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee▶ 0:02:08, and argued the hearing amounted to "scapegoating immigrants" for the economy▶ 0:02:31; in her formal opening statement she said DOT's rule could remove up to 5% of commercial drivers from the road▶ 0:14:21 and argued existing law already bars undocumented immigrants from holding CDLs▶ 0:16:53.

• Mr. Tim Tipton, Commissioner, Oklahoma Department of Public Safety▶ 0:19:15: Said Oklahoma Highway Patrol sent all 730 officers through ICE's 287(g) credentialing process▶ 0:19:45 and that a September 2025 I-40 operation resulted in 90 arrests of illegal CMV operators in roughly 24 hours▶ 0:20:14; described encountering a CDL listing the driver's name as "no name given"▶ 0:21:06 and said an EAD alone is an inadequate qualifier for CDL issuance▶ 0:22:07.

• The Honorable Richard Del Toro, Jr., Sheriff, St. Lucie County▶ 0:24:20: Described the August 12, 2025 Florida Turnpike crash that killed three people, caused by an illegally present driver who had failed a CDL test in Washington ten times before obtaining one in California▶ 0:24:45▶ 0:44:31; detailed Florida's stricter verification steps, including in-person issuance, SAVE-system checks, and English-only testing▶ 0:45:25▶ 0:46:21.

• Ms. Wendy Liu, Attorney, Public Citizen Litigation Group▶ 0:26:27: Testified that CDL standards, including English proficiency, are identical for citizens and documented immigrants▶ 0:28:34▶ 1:03:00; said DOT's own data shows only 17 of roughly 4,000 annual fatal crashes involved a non-citizen, meaning over 99% are caused by U.S. citizens or lawful permanent residents▶ 0:29:28; warned the rule would remove 200,000 experienced drivers, a 5% workforce reduction▶ 0:39:52.

• Representative Fong▶ 0:31:37: Introduced Delila Coleman and her family in the audience▶ 0:31:37 and detailed her 2024 San Bernardino County crash and injuries▶ 0:32:52; asked Commissioner Tipton about states' role in preventing future tragedies and California's sanctuary-state policies▶ 0:33:44▶ 0:36:07.

• Committee member (name garbled in captions)▶ 0:37:23: Noted truckers move nearly three-quarters of U.S. freight▶ 0:37:23; asked Ms. Liu how DOT's rule would harm the economy, drawing her estimate of a 35% rise in a New Jersey–to–Texas freight rate due to driver shortages▶ 0:39:23▶ 0:40:05; entered a Teamsters California letter opposing the rule into the record▶ 0:40:21.

• Representative Van Eps▶ 0:42:26: Cited a Tennessee crash caused by a non-English-speaking illegal alien holder of a CDL that killed one person▶ 0:42:32; asked Sheriff Del Toro about the St. Lucie County crash's impact and Florida's reforms▶ 0:43:33; later asked Commissioner Tipton about vetting for sensitive cargo such as ports and military bases▶ 0:59:08.

• Representative Strong▶ 0:47:17: Noted his own family's history holding a CDL for a bus fleet▶ 0:47:48; highlighted Alabama joint-enforcement operations removing unsafe drivers▶ 0:48:26 and asked Tipton and Del Toro about the importance of state-federal coordination▶ 0:49:28▶ 0:51:33.

• Subcommittee Chairman (self-recognized for questioning)▶ 0:52:40: Highlighted DOT's February 13, 2026 final rule tightening non-domicile CDL eligibility▶ 0:52:56; pressed Tipton on further federal and state actions, eliciting testimony that non-domicile CDL holders identified in Oklahoma came from countries including India, Uzbekistan, China, Russia, and Cuba▶ 1:07:32; raised concerns about insurance documents being shuffled between vehicles▶ 1:08:17.

Key moments

• Ranking Member's parliamentary inquiry challenged the subcommittee's jurisdiction over CDL issuance, arguing it belongs to the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee; the chair responded by citing DHS's role in verifying lawful presence and 287(g) agreements with states▶ 0:02:08▶ 0:02:47.

• Chair cited DOT audits: 1-in-5 non-domicile CDLs failed standards in Illinois, California illegally issued 17,000 non-domiciled CDLs, and over 50% of New York's non-domicile CDLs violated federal law▶ 0:07:03▶ 0:07:32.

• Chair said 17 fatal crashes involving illegal aliens driving commercial vehicles with CDLs caused 30 deaths in 2025, including the St. Lucie County crash that killed three after a driver who had failed a Washington CDL test ten times obtained one in California▶ 0:07:32▶ 0:08:00▶ 0:08:28.

• Sheriff Del Toro detailed the fatal St. Lucie County crash: an illegal U-turn on the Florida Turnpike caused vehicles traveling near 80 mph to strike the truck, killing three▶ 0:44:04▶ 0:44:31.

• Tipton testified Oklahoma Highway Patrol took over 450 CMV operators into custody for immigration violations since late summer 2025, with a single I-40 operation yielding 90 arrests in roughly a day▶ 0:20:39▶ 0:20:14.

• Liu stated DOT's own data shows only 17 of about 4,000 annual fatal crashes involved a documented immigrant — over 99% caused by U.S. citizens or lawful permanent residents — and that CDL standards, including English testing, are identical regardless of immigration status▶ 0:29:28▶ 1:03:00.

• Direct disagreement: Liu argued excluding documented immigrants would remove 200,000 experienced drivers (a 5% workforce cut) and increase fatigue-related risk▶ 0:39:52, while the chair and Republican members argued lax state verification, not documented status, is the safety problem▶ 0:53:22.

• Tipton described a joint OHP-ICE stop finding a passenger van with eight unidentifiable people whose passports were held by the driver of a semi-truck stopped nearby, and cited discoveries of active warrants for human smuggling, drug trafficking, and money laundering among CMV operators▶ 1:09:23▶ 1:09:43.

• Del Toro outlined Florida's reforms: non-domiciled licenses issued only for a year or the length of legal status, in-person issuance, SAVE-system verification, English-only testing, and a pause on non-domicile CDL issuance from November 24, 2025 pending new FMCSA rules▶ 0:45:25▶ 0:46:21.

• Chair noted non-domicile CDL holders encountered in Oklahoma came from countries including India, Uzbekistan, Georgia, Kyrgyzstan, China, Pakistan, Russia, Belarus, Ukraine, Turkey, Cuba, Guatemala, and Venezuela▶ 1:07:32.

Metadata

CommitteeHomeland Security Subcommittee on Oversight, Investigations, and Accountability
Chamber / CongressHouse · 119th Congress
DateMarch 4, 2026
TypeHearing
Witnesses
Ms. Wendy Liu — Attorney, Public Citizen Litigation Group
Mr. Tim Tipton — Commissioner, Oklahoma Department of Public Safety
The Honorable Richard Del Toro, Jr. — Sheriff, St. Lucie County, St. Lucie County Sheriff's Office
Videoyoutube
Transcript191 caption blocks · 10,570 words · 1:11:18 runtime
EventCongress.gov 118972