▶ 0:24:43The subcommittee on early childhood, Elementary, and Secondary Education will come to order. I note that a quorum is present. Without objection, the chair is authorized to call recess at any time. AI is transforming schools across America. According to a Walton Family Foundation report, 60% of US public school teachers used an AI tool for their work during the 2024 2025 academic year. That number was up by nearly double from the previous year.
▶ 0:25:10With AI tools, educators can more easily perform a wide range of classroom functions like analyzing student performance, creating lesson plans, and personalizing curriculum to help students succeed. However, this rapid shift also presents major challenges. 70% of teachers admit they don't feel prepared to use the AI effectively in their classrooms. Over 90% say they need additional support from their school leaders to leverage AI effectively in the classroom.
▶ 0:25:38As America's schools and classrooms are revolutionized by AI, it is imperative we understand the benefits and the challenges of this technology. So let's start with the positives. AI has enormous potential, potentially limitless potential to slash teachers administrative and planning workload, freeing up more time for teaching kids. Teachers who use his AI tools weekly estimate they save about six hours a week over a school year. This adds up to nearly six weeks of extra teaching time.
▶ 0:26:07In a world where thousands of teachers feel stressed or mounting burnout, AI can help teachers save time so that they could focus more on what they do best. We also know that teachers are generally pleased with the quality of work AI helps them produce. For instance, 74% report that AI helps them produce higher quality administrative work. Virtually no, none say that AI worsens their administrative work.
▶ 0:26:32It's hard to imagine another education technology that holds so much potential to make teachers jobs easier. But this potential also comes with challenges. Well, a vast majority of teachers say AI tools can help in the classroom. And an even larger swath of teachers, a staggering 85% express concern about student use of AI. Of course, student misuse of AI will have direct consequences for teachers.
▶ 0:26:56According to a recent survey by Impact Research, nearly 40% of middle and high school students admit they've used AI without teachers permission to complete assignments. And according to the center for democracy and technology, 71% of teachers report that students use of AI is creating an additional burden on them to discern if student work is AI generated or not.
▶ 0:27:19Detecting AI fueled cheating is exceptionally difficult in some cases as existing tools are not always adequate and frequently produce false positives. Students aren't just using these tools to get homework done faster. By the way, excessive or irresponsible use of AI as a crutch threatens to replace critical thinking, especially when used outside of teacher supervision. These problems have obvious consequences as educators must fundamentally rethink how they design assessments, assign homework, and ensure academic integrity.
▶ 0:27:50Unfortunately, teachers report receiving insufficient guidance on how to handle these challenges. For example, according to a recent Rand survey, only 34% of teachers reported their school or district has policies on academic integrity and AI. That's why this hearing is so critical. Today, we'll further illuminate the benefits and challenges of AI adoption for teachers.
▶ 0:28:11We'll hear testimony today about how teachers can be equipped with the tools they need, what support they need from their leadership, and how teachers can best work with students in an era when seemingly everyone is experimenting with AI, and where AI advancements are only going to increase in the months and years to come.
▶ 0:28:29We'll also hear expert advice about what state and local leaders can do to ensure their teacher workforce is ready for the AI Artificial intelligence has unprecedented potential to aid teachers and enrich education. But that potential must be analyzed soberly soberly with a clear view of the potential risks. And with that, I'll turn to the ranking member for an opening statement.
▶ 0:28:52Uh thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to the witnesses. It's encouraging that there's a a lot of common ground, Mr. Chairman, and and the things you brought up today with the opportunities and the challenges. We know that artificial intelligence is already being used in schools across the country for better or worse. AI technologies can provide teachers and students with personalized materials and adaptive learning systems that can tailor classroom activities to individual students. But there are still many concerns as you noted, Mr.
▶ 0:29:17Chairman, and if used in inappropriately, AI could violate students privacy, exacerbate existing disparities, and quash critical thinking skills. There must be caution in implementing AI in our children's education. And to minimize risks, students and teachers need appropriate tools and resources to educate responsibly.
▶ 0:29:37In a world increasingly driven by technology and to responsibly incorporate AI into education, there should be a focus on the people who will directly administer it, the teachers. Right now, teachers are routinely being asked to do more with with less, often while receiving inadequate support and sometimes inadequate pay. Chronic underfunding of public education and cuts to funding for professional development contribute to widening achievement gaps.
▶ 0:30:04Many teachers are turning to AI to lighten their load to help them. And some use AI to create lesson plans, to translate languages, and to provide personalized instruction. As I mentioned, those can be beneficial if done properly by educators who have received appropriate knowledge and training. But unfortunately, that's not what is happening.
▶ 0:30:23For example, in a full comm committee hearing just last month on January 24th, 2026, Alexandra Reeves Given from the Center for Democracy and Technology testified that onethird of students report having personal conversations with AI using schoolprovided devices or platforms, but only one in 10 teachers had training or information about how to respond if they suspect a student's AI use is detrimental to their well-being.
▶ 0:30:49Miss Reeve Given also testified that in one study, half of students agreed that using AI in class makes them feel less connected to their teacher and seven in 10 teachers worried that AI weakens important skills that students need to learn. I would like to enter the testimony of Miss Reeve Given into the
▶ 0:31:09Without objection.
▶ 0:31:10Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Many concerns have been raised about the possibility of AI affecting critical thinking as you mentioned, Mr. Chairman, and I share that concern. I understand that today we are discussing K12 education, but it's important to note that many tech companies are now hiring humanities majors because they can think critically and creatively. For example, Daniela Amode, the president and co-founder of Anthropic, studied literature. And here's what she said.
▶ 0:31:37Her company looks for great communicators, high emotional intelligence, kindness, compassion, curiosity, and people who want to help others. I'd like to enter into the article into the record an article from Business Insider titled anthrop anthropic com co-founder said she doesn't regret her literature major and says AI will make humanities majors more important into the record.
▶ 0:31:59Without objection.
▶ 0:32:00Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I bring that up today because that kind of learning starts early and it's important today's conversation. I'm working on a comprehensive human- centered framework to address AI education and workforce readiness. And among other things, my bill will support educator and institutional readiness by promoting professional development, evidence-based practices, shared resources for responsible AI use, and model curricula backed by research on AI's effects on teaching and learning.
▶ 0:32:28My framework recognizes educators as essential to a thriving workforce and provides resources for schools to adapt AI thoughtfully and responsibly without federal mandates on curriculum or pedagogy. The rising use of AI in schools and in society without federal oversight is indicative of a wider problem. Without proper funding and resources, overwhelmed educators may be left with little choice but to use underresourced and researched technologies to try to meet their goals.
▶ 0:32:58Unfortunately, instead of using our power in Congress to help teachers in schools, my Republican colleagues appear to support the Trump administration's dismantling of the Department of Education, which, I note, eliminated the Office of Educational Technology and illegally withholding education funds from states. This issue has serious short-term and long-term consequences.
▶ 0:33:19The Department of Education should play a pivotal role in helping to close achievement gaps so all students can have access to high-quality public education and that includes funding professional development. Historically, the department has helped provide critical resources to assist states, schools, and districts and navigating technological challenges. And what this administration has done to the department has diminished or even obliterated its capacity to provide these resources.
▶ 0:33:45So, if we're serious about helping those who choose to leverage AI in classrooms to clo close achievement gaps, all students and teachers must have access to these tools. I represent a lot of rural communities, and I'll tell you, the department uses Title One funds to provide resources to schools that need it the most, including rural and underserved communities. And according to the National Education Association, at least 16 million students still live without access to the resources necessary for technology education.
▶ 0:34:13Without the department's leadership or without the department, many schools, particularly in less affluent areas, will go without new technologies. This will likely further widen achievement gaps and leave more children behind. And we must also be vigilant that the AI tools teachers use to prepare lessons and instruct students do not reinforce existing biases or discrimination. Bias and AI algorithms could lead to unfair decision-making in how and what students need in the classroom.
▶ 0:34:43If left unchecked, this could have catastrophic effects for millions of students and teachers. Our role in Congress should be straightforward but far from simple. A public school system in which every student has access to highquality education. So, Congress must rise to the occasion, provide responsible guardrails for the use of AI in classrooms, increase federal investment in education and particularly technology education, and see that teachers are paid a fair salary.
▶ 0:35:09So with that in mind, I would like to enter into the record the American Federation of Teachers common sense guard rails for using advanced technology in schools. It's a report uh into the record.
▶ 0:35:19Without objection.
▶ 0:35:20Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It's often said that education is a calling. House Democrats will continue to fight to give teachers and students the resources and tools they need to fulfill that calling and provide the best education to students today, tomorrow, and for generations to come. And I look forward to the testimony and yield back. Pursuant to committee rule 8C, all members who wish to insert written statements into the record may do so by submitting them to the committee clerk electronically in Microsoft Word format by 5:00 p.m. 14 days after this hearing.
▶ 0:35:45And without objection, the hearing record will remain open for 14 days to allow such statements and other extraneous material noted during the hearing to be submitted for the official hearing record. I'll now introduce our witnesses. Our first witness is Miss Michelle Blat, the state superintendent of schools for the West Virginia Department of Education in Charleston, West Virginia. Our second witness is Mr. Anish Sohony, CEO of Teach for America in New York City. Our third witness is Dr.
▶ 0:36:13David Sikis representing the American Association of Colleges of Teacher Education from Vald Dosta, Georgia. And our fifth fourth witness is Mrs. Allison Knox, senior director of education and workforce policy at Microsoft in Washington DC. We thank the witnesses for being here today and we look forward to your testimony. Pursuant to committee rules, I would ask you each limit your oral presentation to a three-minute summary of your written statement. As committee members have many questions for you, the clock will countdown from three minutes.
▶ 0:36:42However, pursuant to committee rule 8D and committee practice, we will not cut off your testimony until you reach the five-minute mark. I'd also like to remind the witnesses to be aware of your responsibility to provide accurate information to the subcommittee. With that, I will first recognize Ms. Blat for your testimony. Chairman Kylie Raiken ranking member Bonamichi and members of the committee. Thank you for the opportunity to be here today.
▶ 0:37:08As the 34th state superintendent of schools in West Virginia, I provide strategic leadership for our public education system to implement our statewide priorities. I am also a member of the board of directors for the council of the chief state school officers. Our teachers are excited about the cost times saving that they have seen with the use of AI as you've mentioned in your opening remarks to differentiate instruction for our students and develop lesson plans that have engaging activities and are able to meet the needs of our students.
▶ 0:37:38West Virginia currently has about uh is West excuse me West Virginia currently has more teachers participating in the Microsoft co-pilot teach module than any other state and this is a tool that allows them to insert the grade level the standards they wish to teach to get a variety of lesson plans and activities that they are able to implement in their classrooms.
▶ 0:38:00While these resources are very beneficial to our teachers and time-saving has already been mentioned, it's important to remember that AI in the classroom will never replace our teachers. It is important that we continue with our teachers to provide that meaningful relationship that is so important in our classroom experience. Our students also rely on our teachers to be guided on the effective uses of artificial intelligence. So, we encourage our teachers to provide these experiences for students in a safe space where they can learn.
▶ 0:38:30Um, if you walked into some of our middle school classrooms today, you would see students what appears to be in playing Minecraft when in reality reality they are going through a series of lessons from the Prodigy learning modules on understanding AI and safe use of AI. Our superintendent association has also spent a great deal of time learning over the past year about the resources to help them more effectively do their job where it comes to data analysis and administrative tasks.
▶ 0:38:59And all of these things have been beneficial to allow our administrators and superintendent to get out into the schools and do more engagement with our students. Our guidance that we adopted uh in West in 2024 allowed us to begin to put some guard rails and some cautions on the information that our schools were receiving on AI.
▶ 0:39:22We chose to do guidance due to the fact that we knew this was a quickly changing world for artificial intelligence and we did not want to be able not to adjust quickly on the guidance that we needed out in our schools. We've since adjusted and done some edits twice to our guidance documents as new things have come up. We also completed a stakeholder survey where we had our school and district staff along with family and communicator communities tell us what they want to do with AI.
▶ 0:39:5297% of those respondents wanted to make sure that we were keeping literacy, numeracy, and critical thinking skills in place. However, they were also quick to point out that they did not want to limit too much of the AI technology because they knew our students would need that to be prepared for jobs in the future. So, our experience has shown that this flexibility that we're providing our states and districts has really worked out for our schools. We're able to add to resources quickly.
▶ 0:40:19We're able to make changes and we're able to provide the supports um that our teachers need for effective implementation. We strongly believe that the work that we do with our districts is better than what we mandate to our districts. And so we're eager to continue working with our districts to expand the effective use of AI. And I thank you again for the opportunity to be here and to share the great work we're doing and answer any questions you may have.
▶ 0:40:44Thanks very much. I'll next recognize Mr. Soony for your testimony. Chairman Kylie, ranking member Bonamichi, and members of the subcommittee, thank you for the opportunity to testify on teaching in the age of AI. My name is Anish Sahonyi, and I serve as the chief executive officer of Teach for America, a national nonprofit focused on expanding access to an excellent education for all children. I'm a former teacher, have worked in schools, school systems, and education organizations for my entire career.
▶ 0:41:14And for over 35 years, Teach for America has been recruiting and developing high impact educators and have fostered a network of more than 72,000 education leaders nationwide serving in 37 states in the District of Columbia. As has been shared already, we are in a moment of rapid change in education. AI is already present in classrooms.
▶ 0:41:37Three years ago, we saw how quickly this technology was evolving and began to consider how we'll prepare teachers and students to use this technology thoughtfully and responsibly. Through that work, a few clear lessons have emerged. First, AI cannot replace teachers. AI is a tool, not the primary driver of learning. The future of learning will require a blending of technology and human expertise with teachers leading and guiding and technology supporting.
▶ 0:42:06Students learn best when they feel seen, safe, and connected. We know that relationships drive learning. Second, AI must be used alongside strong teaching methods, rigorous content, high-quality curriculum, assessments, and also direct insights from students. This ensures that AI strengthens, not undermines, critical learning conditions.
▶ 0:42:31Third, teachers must have the opportunity to shape AI through hands-on professional development to understand where it adds value, where it might fall short, and how to use it responsibly to drive student outcomes. Finally, AI must improve both effic efficiency and effectiveness for teachers. It should reduce administrative burdens, strengthen instructional design, and free teachers to spend time on personalized learning and human connections. Let me share an example.
▶ 0:43:01I recently had an opportunity to visit a classroom in Los Angeles. The class was called mechatronics, which meant students were tasked with working in teams to blend math, computer, and sciut science, and engineering to build a product that was of interest to them. I watched as students used AI to support their projects. But what really drove the learning wasn't just AI. It was the teamwork, critical thinking, and collaboration happening amongst the students in class.
▶ 0:43:30The teacher guided the experience. AI certainly supported the work, but relationships and human skills drove the learning. Since 2024, more than 4,800 of our teachers have received training on how to use AI responsibly, understanding where it helps, where it doesn't, and how to keep students at the center of their decision-making.
▶ 0:43:52We encourage our teachers to experiment with AI to help them build deeper understanding of the technology, to build confidence, and to hone their judgment on how to use this technology. Our teachers use AI to build durable skills like critical thinking and deep content understanding. For example, one teacher used AI to insert an incorrect step into a math problem, requiring students to identify the mistake, using it for deep reason and reasoning and error analysis, not for shortcuts.
▶ 0:44:22As I close, I want to emphasize that AI's impact, whether positive or negative, on education, is not a foregone conclusion. The choices we make will ultimately help determine whether this technology helps or harms educators and students. With your partnership, we can ensure that AI expands opportunity while thoughtfully managing its risks. Thank you again for this opportunity and I look forward to your questions.
▶ 0:44:47Thanks very much. I'll next recognize Dr. Sikheis for your testimony.
▶ 0:44:52Thank you, Chairman Kylie and Ranking Member Bonamichi, members of the committee. My name is David Sly. I'm representing AACT here today. I'm also the chair of the National Technology Leadership Summit and it is an honor and privilege to be able to discuss this topic with you here today. I think it is important that we first recognize that AI is not a future technology. AI is here and it is absolutely being used in schools as people have given examples. Teachers are using it to aid in lesson plan writing and creating assignments.
▶ 0:45:21Students are using it to create content both written and images, video and music and as an as a tutor. AI is really good at some of these things in helping teachers. It can create leveled reading assignments so that teachers can get reading passages that are adapted for each person in their classroom. But there are also some things that it's being used for that AI is not good at, including grading essays. Too often AI systems are both biased and inconsistent when used in that uh application.
▶ 0:45:50And it is clear that there is no consistent use from teacher to teacher within a school or from school to school or even from district to district. I think what everyone is really looking for is guidance and guard rails on how AI should be used. Teachers want to use it but they don't really know how much to use it. And it's hard to create that guidance because the technology itself is changing so fast.
▶ 0:46:14If a policy would have been written in 2023, that policy would have focused almost entirely on how not to use chat GGP GPT for cheating. If that policy is written today, instead I think it's going to be at how AI can help learners and how it can help teachers and not be focused directly on cheating. But this is leaving states and school districts all to scramble to create their own right now.
▶ 0:46:40Um, as ranking member Bonich Mei mentioned, there is no office of educational technology who could help with this. The National Education Technology Plan that they produced could have helped provide a framework for some of this work. In fact, when I read the testimony from Mrs. Knox here at Microsoft at the five bullets at the end that she proposes, I thought would be perfect to hand over directly to the OE for them to carry out. One thing that we can all agree on is the importance of the teacher.
▶ 0:47:08uh AI is not going to replace teachers. We are all here today having this discussion about AI because sometime in the past engineers, computer scientists, programmers had teachers that inspired them to create this AI technology. If you really think about it, there is no career that doesn't start in the classroom. But these teachers need help. As we've all mentioned, they need help with professional development. Professional development is not easy.
▶ 0:47:38It takes the two most precious resources that are in schools, time and money. If professional development is done as a oneoff where someone comes in, leads a workshop, and then they leave, that technology is not going to be widely adapted. Instead, it needs to be consistent throughout the year. There needs to be a coach in that school that is going into the classrooms with the teachers, showing them examples of how to use the AI effectively.
▶ 0:48:04and then you can get consistent adaption across the across the building. We need to be very careful and learn from the mistakes we made in the last 10 to 15 years with technology. In that time, schools were in a rush to put phones, tablets, Chromebooks in schools and get a screen in front of every student. I think now the data is very clear that did not work.
▶ 0:48:29the students did not learn the content better and their social and emotional health has suffered greatly. We need to ensure as we move forward teaching about and with AI that we do not become overly tech reliant and that critical thinking skills remain imperative. So in conclusion, AI is being used but there's a lack of consistency and guidance. Teachers are not going to be replaced. They are too vital to the student learning process.
▶ 0:48:56Highquality professional development is needed and it takes time and money and we have to learn from our recent past. I urge us to be careful. It may be a great mantra for a tech company to move fast and break things when the thing that gets broken as an app. If you're a teacher, the thing that gets broken is a student. So instead of moving fast, teachers need to move intentionally with technology.
▶ 0:49:20Instead of breaking things, they need to nurture nurture those students as those students are going to become the next generation of doctors, engineers, and politicians that will lead us into an AI rich future. Thank you for your time.
▶ 0:49:35Thank you very much. And uh lastly, I will recognize Mrs. Knox for your
▶ 0:49:40Thank you. [clears throat] Thank you, chair, ranking member, and members of the subcommittee. My name is Allison Knox, and I'm the senior director of education and workforce policy at Microsoft. and it's my honor to be here today to share ideas about teaching in the age of AI. I have a special role at Microsoft. I serve as a bridge between the education and workforce communities and the company. I talk with teachers and parents to gain their perspectives on how AI is impacting teaching and learning.
▶ 0:50:10I am just one of many at Microsoft that serves in this capacity to ensure that their insights flow back into our programs, our products, and our policies. Through these conversations, there are three themes that consistently emerge. First, teachers want the skills, knowledge, and support to build AI literacy and critical thinking in their students. Parents also are asking about how this technology works.
▶ 0:50:37Second, teachers and parents want guidance and guardrails. They want to know that their students data is safe and that an adult is fully in charge of classroom technologies. Third, teachers want classroom AI tools. They want a seat at the technology table and they want opportunities to provide feedback that improves these tools.
▶ 0:51:02Of the many recent conversations I've had with educators across the country, here are two that reinforce these themes. First, I spoke with a middle school science teacher at a public charter school in California. 20% of her students have disabilities. She uses AI to generate lesson plans that highlight hands-on learning activities to meet all of her students individualized needs.
▶ 0:51:30This frees her up to focus on dynamic classroom discussions to help deepen her students critical thinking skills. Second, a group of West Virginia educators recently met with our product designers and discussed several technical ideas based on actual classroom use. Now, engineers are working to integrate their suggestions back into our products for that state.
▶ 0:51:58Through these and ongoing feedback loops and other real-time insights and best practices, here are three policy recommendations for you to consider. First, support professional development for teachers that is co-designed by them and focuses on how to teach about and with AI. Second, provide guidance on how to operate AI systems in school districts in a safe and protected way.
▶ 0:52:27Third, promote AI literacy across the United States. Embed AI literacy throughout the curriculum at all grade levels and in all subjects. At the end of the day, our efforts around AI and education are grounded in listening and learning with teachers and parents to ensure greater student success through the safe and responsible use of AI. Thank you and I look forward to your questions.
▶ 0:52:57Thank you very much. Under committee rule nine, we will now question witnesses under the five minute rule. Uh I'll first recognize the chair of the full committee, Mr. Wahberg for five
▶ 0:53:10Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thanks to the panel for being here. I think if you look at our hearing schedules, you'll realize that we're taking AI seriously. Um whether we understand it or not, we need to know about it and new know best practices. Uh Superintendent Blatt, welcome here. Uh we hear consistently that teachers feel overworked and stressed and we know that is true in many many cases.
▶ 0:53:37While AI can save teachers, time um getting trained can also take time and in certain cases cause stress. Additionally, you touched on this in your testimony, but how do you ensure that AI training equips teachers rather than becoming just another in their to-do list?
▶ 0:54:04Your microphone, please.
▶ 0:54:07Thank you. We have a lot of information available and professional learning resources on our professional learning management system that our teachers can access at any time. But from experience and talking with our teachers, many of the tools they are currently using in the classroom have not taken a lot of time to learn how to use um even when we speak about the Minecraft education and the programs that we're doing with the students, the training is maybe a 90minute virtual session and then they walk through that with their students.
▶ 0:54:36And so our experience has been that while the professional learning and the effective use of this technology is important, um it's not taking the level of training that we've seen with other things that we've rolled out in the
▶ 0:54:48Okay. Okay. Well, that is always going to be a creative tension, isn't it?
▶ 0:54:54Yes, absolutely.
▶ 0:54:56Thank you. Um Mr. Sahonyi, uh, you mentioned that some teachers are using AI to customize, uh, the instruction for their students. In your written testimony, you mentioned one teacher in Houston who achieved a 20% increase in test scores. I wish that that person had been my teacher at certain points. That kind of improvement is is remarkable. So, how did AI enable such massive improvement?
▶ 0:55:25And do you think that other teachers could replicate those same results?
▶ 0:55:30Thank you for the question. So in that example, the teacher in Houston took text uh for a classroom who was who had students that were speaking over 52 different languages. And so they were able to use AI to ensure the text was able to be translated into the languages that met the students where they were without reducing the complexity of the text at the same time. Right? It's important to make sure we keep a high standard.
▶ 0:55:55Something else that teacher was able to do was also to then be able to spend more time with the students, motivating the students to be able to access that technology. I think this example speaks to a broader idea that AI has the potential to help support the personalization of learning opportunities for students while at the same time freeing up the teacher.
▶ 0:56:16it would have taken that teacher way too long to try to replicate the different languages on their own to then spend that time building relationships with the students to motivate those students to strive to achieve their goals as well. So I think the combination of technology and the combination of the relationships the teacher is enable a able to build can really support achieving the student outcomes we care about.
▶ 0:56:38interesting that that could bring up another hearing on how we can take a multiplicity of ethnic groups, languages that are here in America, but still turn that AI training into bringing people back to English as well. Something that I think most our American citizens would say is integral in bringing the the the nation together. And um that'll be another another subject, Mr.
▶ 0:57:06chairman that we could look at in the future as well. Uh Mrs. Knox, you mentioned in your written testimony that one of teachers biggest fears around AI use is student privacy. Uh what advice would you give to teachers who want to use AI responsibly and without compromising student data?
▶ 0:57:26Yes, thank you for the question and it safety I think is going to be probably a big theme of today's hearing. Um, there is no question that student data privacy is on everybody's minds when it comes to AI and I'm speaking to our products when it comes to the purview of a school district. Um, I can say for sure that the company does not leverage the students data um to inform any of our AI models nor do we provide it to any third-party providers.
▶ 0:57:55But in addition to that, we make sure that the district is fully in charge of the technology. So in other words, they can monitor what is happening for in inappropriate use potentially. They can also filter out information that may not be appropriate for that district. And then also they enter into an agreement with us that they will not allow a child under the age of 13 to use a chatbot.
▶ 0:58:21So that all combined including asking teachers to always be trained very consistently that when they use any sort of chatbot they are never inputting any personally identifiable information into that chatbot of a teacher or a student. So those five elements combined create this very safe environment when using Microsoft technologies.
▶ 0:58:43Thank you. I yield back.
▶ 0:58:45I'll now recognize the uh ranking member of the full committee, Mr. Scott for five minutes.
▶ 0:58:49Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Um, Mrs. Blatt, could you, you're the state superintendent. Could you tell me the advantages or disadvantages in statewide versus local guidance on the use of a uh
▶ 0:59:05where we have so many regular or so many rural districts in our state, one of the things that that we do for a lot of our state our districts is really to focus on providing a service in some things that they don't have the expertise in. And so by putting out this guidance, we enabled them to be able to adapt it to their own confines and figure out what it worked for their individual teachers.
▶ 0:59:29And so we try at the state level to always provide the resources, the tools, and the guidance to our districts, but allow them to locally design what works best for them.
▶ 0:59:38And does that guidance include guidance used by students as well as teachers?
▶ 0:59:44Yes, sir.
▶ 0:59:46Um, thank you, Mr. Sahony. Um, you essentially said that you want to use AI when it helps and not use it when it doesn't help. Uh, how do teachers and students figure out the difference?
▶ 1:00:00Yeah, we train our educators starting before they enter the classroom to understand what responsible and ethical use of AI looks like. So in my testimony, I shared the example of one of our educators who inserted an incorrect step in a math problem to support students to do the deep reasoning and critical thinking necessary to understand how to solve the problem. That emerged because we were able to train our teachers in understanding why that would enable critical thinking.
▶ 1:00:28We were able to also hedge against or guard against the risk that a student then enters the math problem into a chatbot and get gets the answer back to them. So while there are no guarantees, our bet is that if we train and support teachers and educators in understanding how the technology works and how the technology can drive critical thinking, they can also support their students to do the same.
▶ 1:00:50And you said um we who is we providing the training?
▶ 1:00:54Yeah. So I run an organization called Teach for America and we support and train novice teachers as well as first and second year teachers through coaching and development. And so we um take the foundations of what we know of effective teaching practices and teaching pedigogy, what we know about how students learn and implement that
▶ 1:01:14Um M Dr. Sack House um you mentioned things like keep critical thinking skills and things like that. Uh again who can provide the professional development so that people can learn? I mean people that guidance doesn't just drop out of the air. Where do you get
▶ 1:01:40There are a variety of people who have moved into that space. There are there are companies that have moved into the professional development space and offering that. I think you can also look to colleges of teacher education as experts in that to come and provide that training uh for school districts as well as they are learning uh and teaching pres-ervice teachers on how to use the Um Miss Knox, can you answer the same question where you would where someone wants to get guidance on
▶ 1:02:10AI school system where they would get the appropriate guidance? Yeah, it definitely is a great question and I think most of us agree that although we love to engage with online learning, sometimes being in person for a training can really make a huge difference and that's what we've learned through our partnership with the American Federation of Teachers. We have launched with Open AI and Anthropic a new um and uft um the National Academy for AI instruction.
▶ 1:02:40The goal is to train in person and somewhat online. It's a combination 400,000 teachers over the next five years. And what we've learned through that is they want to understand the guardrails document that um Congresswoman Bonamichi put into the record that AFT has put out. That's where they start the training. Then they think through ethical use in their school district and then they actually get hands-on experience with taking a look at what AI can do for them in their classroom.
▶ 1:03:09So, it's three parts, but we are trying to reach out as much as possible in person to teachers across the country.
▶ 1:03:15Well, if a local school board was interested in guidance, where would they look?
▶ 1:03:21Well, there are a couple of um organizations that I'd recommend. One is Teach AI and they can go right up to the local school AI guidance. Um there's a toolkit and a policy guide, both of which I think are phenomenal and endorsed by many educational associations and they are being leveraged in about 34 states.
▶ 1:03:40Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ 1:03:43I'll now uh recognize myself [clears throat] for five minutes. Uh Mr. So Hony, um you uh have kind of a unique vantage point into um the landscape of education in America uh with Teach for America, which uh places recent college graduates at schools all across the country. So, and your uh students or your teachers arrive at their schools uh well trained with how to use AI, but I'm sure they confront a variety of conditions in schools all across the country as far as how AI is being utilized.
▶ 1:04:10Could you give us some sense as to what that landscape looks like? How much variation there is uh in terms of the use of AI in classrooms?
▶ 1:04:18Yeah, thank you for the question. educa I mean AI technology in education in classrooms is here as we've all covered and given that we work in 37 states in DC in rural America urban America uh we have a vast landscape of where we where we have experience and what we find is there's great variance in terms of the technology tools that have been adopted by these school systems and so our focus is on ensuring we help our educators learn how to work with and use those tools no matter what the tool
▶ 1:04:48is again responsibly and ethically and also to drive personalized learning so that they can focus on things that motivate them like relationship building.
▶ 1:04:58Yeah. The heart of uh TFA's mission is to close the achievement gap that exists in uh in American uh education. Do you see AI as a as a sort of tool for doing
▶ 1:05:08I think there's huge promise and there's huge risk at the same time. I think the promise which is what I want to anchor in because you know AI is here. Students and educators are using it is that it can really deliver a personalized learning opportunity for students. It can ensure that all students get exactly what they need to drive forward their outcomes. I think it can also ensure that students and teachers are able to build the kind of very real human relationships that only educators are able to build as well.
▶ 1:05:37At the same time, I think it is not a foregone conclusion that we will have that future in large part because if this technology goes into schools and into classrooms without support for students or without training for teachers, uh it could also be used for in ways that diminish critical thinking that students are doing or could be used as a shortcut to drive uh seemingly drive forward student outcomes but ultimately do not.
▶ 1:06:02Yeah, I think that's really key and the point raised by Mrs. knocks about uh supporting professional development across the country uh I think is is really vital because uh I think that this technology does have extraordinary power to close achievement gaps but uh if it's adopted in you know ways where it benefits some uh areas but not others it could also serve to exacerbate that gap so uh it's really important that we get it right uh you know finally we've been talking a lot today about uh how AI for teachers can optimize kind of the the back end
▶ 1:06:32of teaching uh if you will in terms of administ administrative tasks uh and so forth. But you know there's also I believe especially as uh models get more advanced the uh opportunity to open up a whole new kinds of pedagogical uh you know experiences and maybe I'll open this up to Mrs. uh Knox as well and as well as uh you Mr. Sony if you've seen this in classrooms. I mean you can readily imagine uh you know once we get to the point where uh 3D worlds can just be generated on command.
▶ 1:06:59You combine that with augmented reality and uh you know you can literally bring history alive for students. You can travel to the bottom of the ocean. You can go toe-to-toe with a Tyrannosaurus Rex. Whatever the case may be. Uh have you seen that in in classrooms at all yet? And and Mrs. Knox, are you guys working on that sort of thing?
▶ 1:07:15Well, I have not gone toe-to-toe with a Tyson Tyson that that but um yeah, I mean I I think also what you're kind of getting at is, you know, is AI ultimately through all of these new experiences that we're bringing to the classroom, is it impacting student achievement? Because I think at the end of the day, we all want student achievement to go, you know, absolutely up.
▶ 1:07:36And one of the policy recommendations, thank you for saying that they were um helpful um that we make is there needs to be more research on how AI is impacting student achievement. And I just wanted to share a quick story with you. I spoke with a high school teacher in Kfax, one of your the high schools. And um I asked him if he felt that his if his students were learning more in the because he's using AI tools. And he emphatically said absolutely yes. And so I asked him to break it down a little bit for me.
▶ 1:08:06and he said, "Basically, my big issue is that I have to engage students for them to actually want to learn. And the best way to do that is to take whatever lesson or concept I'm trying to teach and really focus it on something that they are very interested in." And in the past, I might find out what that is, but it would take me an entire year to shift my curriculum. Now, it takes me potentially a day.
▶ 1:08:30I can get the presentation built, the rubrics built, I can get the research done to prove that all this information is there, and I can verify it. But what that lets me then do is, and now he's using the Socratic teaching method. So now he's got the content, now he's got the Socratic teaching method, he's asking the harder questions, and he's convinced because of all of this, his teacher, his students are learning a lot more.
▶ 1:08:54Fascinating. Well, thank you very much. Uh, I'm out of time. if you have examples and Mrs. Blad as Mrs. Blad as well that you'd like to share uh as the hearing goes on. Those would be great to hear. I'll now recognize the ranking member Ms. Bonamichi.
▶ 1:09:05Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to the witnesses. According to a report for the from the Center for Democracy and Technology, 86% of students and teachers use AI used AI in the last school year, but less than half of teachers and students received either professional development on AI or guidance for its use in schools. And we know many educators and students are rapidly embracing AI for its promise to improve productivity. Thank you, Miss Knox, for that story.
▶ 1:09:31Um, but without clear instruction and support and safeguards, they risk diminished learning outcomes, tech- enabled harassment or bias in a more disconnected classroom. So, it is really about how do we do this in the right way, in a positive way. Um, Dr. Slice it at a 2025 report found that less than onethird of teachers received guidance on how to use AI tools, what AI is, and how it works and how to monitor AI systems. So, what resources could the federal government provide to close these professional development gaps?
▶ 1:10:01And could these resources adequately inform educators about AI related bias, which you mentioned in your testimony, privacy risks, and responsible use? you know beyond just optimizing tasks which is important there's a lot more to it.
▶ 1:10:15Yeah u thank you for the question so I as we've talked about here I think the overall goal is right is getting AI to improve student achievement right and you Mr. So here has access to a huge database of teachers, but we need to study that, right? And we need the incentive. We need the the grants and the research to be able to go out and see are these things that that they're implementing are are they getting the gains that they want because they want to know that too. Everyone wants to know is this being effective?
▶ 1:10:46And so we need to be able to have that ability to run some of these largecale research studies to make sure that how they are how AI is being implemented, you know, which ways are effective, which ways aren't, which ways are leading to student achievement, which ways might be leading to, you know, social and emotional impact that is detrimental. You know, how how we can distinguish all of that. But it it's going to take you can't figure that out overnight. It's going to take a little time and it's going to take a little research.
▶ 1:11:14I've always been a strong supporter of IEES, Institute for Educational Sciences, and of course the Office of Technology at what's left of the Department of Education. I hope that uh that we can fund those and bring them back. I think they play a really really critical role. And several of you have mentioned both student achievement and critical thinking. Uh I'm someone who doesn't just look at test scores. To me, student achievement doesn't just mean a good test score. It means a creative critical thinker.
▶ 1:11:40Um, and we know that AI literacy means more than learning to write prompts, which is, as you said, Dr. Slike, a couple years ago, that might have been it, but there's so much more. People need to know how to critically evaluate AI through ethical, linguistic, and human-based lenses. Um, so I want to ask you, Miss Knox, I've heard, as I mentioned in my testimony, many tech workers and executives recently talking about the importance of critical thinking, which I note all of you mentioned in your testimony, and expressing a decline about really the human factor, the humanities. Do you agree?
▶ 1:12:10Um, and what are your thoughts on why it's necessary for students and educators to use and evaluate AI in the context of its historical, ethical, and social implications?
▶ 1:12:20Yeah, I think again there needs to be more research on this. I um too am a literature um major. I work at a tech company. I've been there a long time. And so I think critical thinking and the humanities are in wonderful places to you know engage in exercises where you're thinking deeply about subjects and then you can transport that thinking capability to other contexts which many companies like Microsoft um definitely value.
▶ 1:12:44We also really value someone who understands the way that you learn and that you want to keep learning and love learning no matter what's coming down the pike. Um I do want you to know that I spoke to many many teachers who believe that because of the tools um they are going deeper with their students on critical thinking. And just I can throw out one example really quickly.
▶ 1:13:04State of New York there's a teacher who is a writing teacher and um she said that most students really do not like um revising writing which is in some ways thinking about your thinking right and I'll just say that most adults don't always like doing that either. Um, so she has found a way for them to describe a scene um that sometimes she uses the prompt herself and sometimes it's the student doesn't really matter.
▶ 1:13:30And then what comes back to the student is a visualization through AI of what it is they wrote.
▶ 1:13:37Well, this gets them very engaged. And guess what? A lot of times what comes
▶ 1:13:42isn't what they thought they wrote.
▶ 1:13:44It's more sort of hands-on projectbased problemolving learning, right? Which
▶ 1:13:48and so they revise their writing. That that's great. We had a a great hearing in this subcommittee on screen time, which is something you you mentioned uh Dr. Sly. Um and I'm almost out of time, but I really quickly want to ask you, Mr. Soani, you said you encourage teachers to experiment with AI, and I I wonder what you learn from that, and what if the experiment doesn't work? How do what do you do with that? And then what if it does work, how do you share that with other educators?
▶ 1:14:13The reason we encourage it is AI is not a tool or a technology that you can just slap into a classroom. It's something an educator has to have experience with and actually really try on. What we found is our educators have increased level of confidence and understanding in the technology when they are able to use it and they're able to have stronger levels of judgment on how to effectively use it. We're in the business of taking what we've learned and sharing that knowledge across the sector and across the field.
▶ 1:14:40And so it's important to us to make sure that the learnings also are spread
▶ 1:14:44I have so many more questions but my time is expired. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Harris of North Carolina is recognized.
▶ 1:14:51Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thanks to all of you on the panel today uh for your uh input and uh and testimonies. Um, Miss Blad, I want to ask you a couple of questions here. I I noticed that the uh West Virginia Department of Education issued a public stakeholder survey where they found the approximately four out of five respondents expressed some degree of concern or worry surrounding the uses of uh the adoption of AI and yet your
▶ 1:15:21state has been able to implement statewide guidance on AI and since then I would just be curious what has been the responses that you've heard from from teachers from parents and from students
▶ 1:15:35Well, I think from our teachers, we've learned a lot um and continue to learn a lot as they work through the different programs and different resources that they have. Um our students, especially the ones that we have engaged with some of our statewide pilots, um feel very engaged with their learning. An example would be with with our Minecraft education. They've been able to engage in a game that they were familiar with while learning the different parts of AI and understanding that.
▶ 1:16:02Um we've had a lot of feedback um especially from parents um around our use. We talk about the social media and the use and of screen time and different things and we've limited that um in our schools here in the last year especially with the use of cell phones.
▶ 1:16:19And so our parents are seeing that when they engage with this technology and some of these AI programs, they're more engaged with that because they're not spending so much time on their cell phones and they've seen a difference in how they're responding and interacting with each other as well.
▶ 1:16:34Okay, that's awesome. Do do you believe that the teachers in your state feel more equipped to handle issues pertaining to academic integrity and AI in the classroom because of the guidance you guys were able to provide? I do believe so.
▶ 1:16:49And an example would be that with our guidance, we train our teachers in like really how to use the AI as opposed to maybe telling a child that I need you to write the definition for your 10 vocabulary words and give me 10 sentences, which a child could do in chat GPT in literally 10 seconds.
▶ 1:17:05Um, we encourage our teachers to put in to the platform themselves, how can I engage students to help them understand how to learn these vocabulary words and how to use them in sentences and then what we get back is a list of activities that are differentiated that we can provide to our students. So, it increases some of the creativity that our teachers are able to use to engage the students.
▶ 1:17:28Awesome. Okay, Mr. Dr. Sahony, I I know from reading your testimony and hearing you today, you believe AI can be a a valuable tool in the classroom with poss proper guard rails. And studies have shown that teachers using AI can save up to six hours per week on prep time, allowing them to focus on their students really more directly.
▶ 1:17:50So, let me ask you, where do you believe the line is between teachers using AI efficiently versus becoming self-reliant on it? I think one of the opportunities we have with AI and education is actually to make the teaching profession itself much more attractive and interesting. I know historically we've had a challenge interest in the teaching profession is at a 50-year low. What we've found is educators are excited about this idea that if I can become a teacher, I can be a leader in my classroom.
▶ 1:18:19I can work with AI and technology to support what I do but and I can focus on what makes me very excited to be a teacher which is to build relationships with students to motivate them to accomplish their goals then it might be a much more interesting profession. So I start there to say I think there is always a fine line between when AI technology can be used and when the teacher at the end of the day is really central to the learning. What we have found is it requires both working together.
▶ 1:18:48And I think there's an opportunity to get even more people interested in the teaching profession with what's available to us.
▶ 1:18:54Well, and as a CEO of Teach for America, you interact with teachers all the time. And so I'll just give you the last minute. What do you think are teachers biggest concerns? And what can principles and superintendent do to help in this matter?
▶ 1:19:09When we talk to teachers, they're worried that they're not going to get the professional development support they need to be able to effectively utilize the tools that their students are using. and the tools that they themselves now have access to. So I think the key here as we've been talking about is making sure educators are supported with understanding how to use this technology. I'll also add I think there's a huge opportunity. One of the things that we're very early on given how how emergent this technology is, but I think there's great potential for is the concept of something like a teaching simulator.
▶ 1:19:39oftentimes novice teachers want to be able to practice and have at bats at doing things like IEP meetings or to practice parent teacher conferences. I think the [clears throat] technology is going to evolve to a place where they'll get that kind of support. So, I think we also hear from educators, let us know how we can take advantage of the technology that's available to us as it evolves so we can strengthen our
▶ 1:20:00Thank you, sir. And thank you all, Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Representative Grahala of Arizona is recognized.
▶ 1:20:07Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Um, Dr. Sleighheis, thank you for joining us today. All of you, thank you for joining us today to discuss the future of the American classroom. In my district in Arizona, CD7, Puma Community College serves as a vital workforce pipeline, partnering with our K12 districts and regional employers to provide job align training. This is especially critical for our significant population of first generation students to build a strong school to career pipeline.
▶ 1:20:35We cannot have our K12 students graduating as mere passive users of technology. They must enter a post-secary education with critical AI literacy that is human- centered skills that translate directly into career success. Right now, most students can navigate AI with ease while their teachers need support and training. So, this conversation is very timely. It's imperative that teachers understand the capabilities, limitations, and the potential impact AI has on teacher student learning.
▶ 1:21:05We must ensure that the tools being used to close the achievement gaps do not inadvertently compromise the privacy or future of the very students we're trying to uplift. As part of guard guardrail discussions, I have to include protections of intellectual property and potential um copyright infringement. Furthermore, I say this as a member who also sits on the natural house natural resources committee.
▶ 1:21:31We must be mindful of the environmental footprint of this growth in our desert communities anywhere, but specifically in our desert communities, the ones that I represent, we must be mind, we must understand that water is a resource not to be wasted. We have to consider the immense energy and water these systems consume and must demand sustainable alternatives that protect our environment just as we protect our classrooms. So with that I would like to ask um Dr.
▶ 1:21:58Syis as an expert who helped develop the teacher educator technology competencies you understand that literacy is the foundation of career mobility beyond simply knowing how to operate a chat box like chat um GPT or claude. What does true AI literacy mean for a K12 teacher in a classroom?
▶ 1:22:19Uh thank you very much for the question. So the teacher educator technology competencies that you referenced are a series of essentially 12 statements with additional bullets on how teacher educators need to model and demonstrate the use of technology for pre-ervice teachers so that they can then in turn be prepared to implement that technology in an effective way in their classroom. A couple of those TET uh sorry I referred to them as the Tetssis instead of saying that out.
▶ 1:22:48um the teacher educator technology competencies like that. Um a couple of them you know that I just want to highlight in particular uh one number nine is you know teacher educators will address the legal ethical and socially responsible use of technology in education. So I think that that you know speaks directly to what you were talking about.
▶ 1:23:06Teachers need to know and and be taught you know in colleges of teacher education about some of the back end of this technology what it is doing how it is working and what you know and many of the issues that you spoke of.
▶ 1:23:20Yeah. And so who is currently defining these standards? Is it tech vendors, district administration, policy makers or the educators themselves? and how can Congress ensure these standards align with industry recognized credentials that institutions like Puma Community College require for the workforce?
▶ 1:23:39So, I would I would say it's kind of a little bit of a wild wild west on who's defining the standards right now. Um, I think you have states like West Virginia who have taken the lead. They're defining what what it's meaning for them. I think um there's a great organization ISTY, the International Society for Technology and Education um ISTY plus ASED. they they have a series of standards they are defining they're pretty wild widely adapted as well.
▶ 1:24:05Um but a lot of cases you don't have state guidance you don't have you know a professional organization like that uh and there isn't any federal guidance coming right now again the national educational technology plan which was put out by the OE would have provided kind of a base framework you know to for a lot of that work. Yeah, thank you. As we push for integration, we know AI systems often train on student inputs, creating significant data privacy risks.
▶ 1:24:34What specific guardrails are needed to prevent the misuse of sensitive student data? And how are you seeing teachers navigate these privacy concerns in practice to protect their students?
▶ 1:24:44Sure. So, you know, as Mrs. not shared. I think when AI is designed specifically for schools, they they there is an absolute effort to close the box so that information is not going out and not being used to train the system. Um, magic school AI, I think, is another good example of this. And I I don't love that name because it implies the AI is magic and it's it's not. There's a real technology and system behind it.
▶ 1:25:10Uh but that aside, but they also advertise that it is a very closed system that that data is not being used. The real danger lies in teachers who don't have the professional development, school districts that can't afford the Microsoft tools, the magic AI tools, who are just using the freely available AI tools on the internet. And when they're inputting things, that's when it really gets dangerous.
▶ 1:25:35Yeah. Thank you um for the extra time. And I yield back,
▶ 1:25:39Mr. Mland of Guam is recognized.
▶ 1:25:41Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This hearing is really important and of course we know we want our students to have AI to be prepared for the future. At the same time, we're trying to figure out what guardrails did we put in to make sure it's safe. And then we don't want to make it so safe or we do want to make it safe, but we want to make sure the student is still having their they got their we're not replacing their fundamental knowledge, you know, learning it on their own. uh but at least it for sure it's really helpful for our teachers so they can really focus back on the on the students.
▶ 1:26:10So question is for Miss Knox uh you know there was that situation in a chat box back in 2016 called Tay which became infamous uh for its offensive and harmful tweets and Microsoft quickly took down the chat box and issued their apology but Tay's introduction showed some of the limitations of AI and how it could be harmful. So what are the lessons that Microsoft learned from Tay and how should the guardrails be implemented when it comes to AIS in
▶ 1:26:39Absolutely and thank you for the question. There's no question for us that adults need to always be involved when students are engaging with these technologies, a teacher and a parent. So that's number one. And then number two, when we're talking about a school district, so in school time, when they're using a, as I would, thank you for saying closed system, it is a closed system. When you're working with Microsoft, the student um under the age of 13 cannot use a chatbot.
▶ 1:27:07And then the older students, they're only interacting with information that that school district deems appropriate for that school. Plus, if the older students if there's inappropriate use when they're in the chatbot, there's a quick monitoring system for the district so they can flag it to the parent or to the teacher.
▶ 1:27:27Furthermore, we really train teachers and parents and students never to put any personalized in um identifiable information into the chatbot so it can never come back up. So, there's a lot more training on that. Um and we make sure that no no matter what all the students data cannot be leveraged to train our models. It cannot be leveraged to be given to third parties. So again it's this ecosystem of safety when it comes to the school
▶ 1:27:58Thank you. And Miss Bleet we know that AI has been used uh to generate inappropriate content. Uh recently there was incidents on Twitter where people were manipulating images of women in a bad way. And we also know that AI can be used uh for cyber bullying. So what can be done about this please?
▶ 1:28:18This is a very uh timely question sir for West Virginia. Um unfortunately in this past school year um we've lost a student to a a cyber bullying um attack and we've sat down with uh the parents of that student and we've talked to them extensively along with our legislators. And what we have discovered is that while we're doing all of these things to educate our teachers and our students, it's sometimes the parents that have been left out of this education piece.
▶ 1:28:49And so, um, Mr. Tate has asked us as we work through this and we think about continuing to adapt our guidance that we ensure that we have guidance out there for parents things that provides them the information on what are the tools, what are the things that are being used, how are they using these in a negative way to, you know, to get to our students and to get to our our younger um students, you know, in our school
▶ 1:29:15Thank you. I'm glad they're really focused on that. That was a sad situation, but it's being addressed. Thank you very much.
▶ 1:29:21Um, Mr. Shouni, uh, one of one of your lessons learned was that AI can be deepened thinking and personalized learning. We've we've heard similar testimonies from several previous witnesses on the same. However, I assume that uh, this is most true for older students. Is it hard to imagine that any of us want kindergartens interacting ex extensively with chatbots?
▶ 1:29:49Certainly AI has to be responsive to what we know uh is true of students who learn at various age levels. There's an example I can share of uh visiting a school where it was an early elementary class and the teacher was teaching phonics instruction. And when you teach phonics, if you're a teacher, you have to be able to see how the student is sounding out the word. And it's very hard to track 30 students sounding out letters.
▶ 1:30:13So, this teacher was able to use an AI tool that tracked sort of how the student was pronouncing the word and how each individual student was pronouncing the word and was able to use them that information, that data to group students based on where they most needed small group instruction. I offer this to say there is no one-sizefits-all answer. You have to be able to differentiate based on the age of your students, but I think there is potential at all age levels if used appropriately.
▶ 1:30:41Thank you very much to our panel. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ 1:30:45Representative Lee of Pennsylvania is
▶ 1:30:53Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Um, teachers in my districts, they have a variety of opinions on AI. Some of them don't feel comfortable uh enough to incorporate it. Others of them are investing their own money um and effort and time into it because they're worried about their students AI literacy. And then there are others who, you know, they they want to learn more about it, but they just don't have the bandwidth. Teachers um there are different levels of comfort and familiarity or exactly why they need resources and support from the Department of Education.
▶ 1:31:24One of the things I hear the most from teachers in my district is a fear and outrage over the department being dismantled right now. My Republican colleagues have mentioned the need to support teachers with AI, but we don't hear any calls from them to restore the Department of Education's eliminated office of educational technology, an office that has and was explicitly designed to provide the support teachers are calling for. Dr. Sycis, in your testimony, you mentioned that without guidance from OT, the void is being filled in part by private tech firms with their own agendas.
▶ 1:31:53Why would you say it is important uh for there to be guidance um on AI in the classroom from an office like OE at the department of education? Uh thank you for the question. So I I do think that that guidance is extraordinarily important. I think when I mentioned there are private companies coming in and and filling that void. Those companies have are have good intentions.
▶ 1:32:21However, at the end of the day, there many of these are forprofit. So, at the end of the day, they are still looking to find a way to make money. To find a way to make money is usually to get someone to use your product. You get someone to use your product by making your product essentially more addictive like the social media examples that we are well aware of at this point. So if without some some federal guidance and some top level guidance to sort of prevent that kind of thing, it just enters into a very dangerous space regardless of how well-intentioned people are.
▶ 1:32:51Thank you. Understood. And concerns about private tech agendas. They're not hypothetical like the FTC has acted against several ad tech companies that misrepresented their products or improperly handled ser uh sensitive student data. Uh the Department of Education should be working to ensure schools are equipped to prevent uh the harmful use of AI in the first place.
▶ 1:33:10We shouldn't have um AI weapon detectors mistaking bags of chips, you know, for guns uh or for their their musical instruments for weapons leading to armed police handcuffing children. And data from AI school surveillance tech shouldn't be used or shared with ICE, an agency with complete disregard for constitutional rights and civil liberties. Mr. Mr. Chairman, I request unanimous consent to enter an article from from the 74 in the Guardian titled ICE taps into school security cameras to aid Trump's immigration crackdown into the record.
▶ 1:33:40Without objection.
▶ 1:33:41Thank you. ICE is using data from AI based school surveillance to aid and abet their mass deportation efforts. This raises serious concerns about what private edtech companies are doing with the data they're collected. Uh Mrs. Knox, while Microsoft has said they don't think ICE is using its tools for mass surveillance, there are reports that ICE substantially increased its reliance on Microsoft's cloud platform and AI tools. When you've spoken with teachers, have any of them expressed any concern about trusting Microsoft's AI tools given the company's connections to
▶ 1:34:11This is a really important issue. Um, it's beyond the purview of my current
▶ 1:34:16Thank you. Um, we do hope and and and I appreciate that response and I hope that uh if you all have get the opportunity that you are able to to dig into that one because it is really important um that we understand where this data is going and how it is being used and that as teachers are expressing concern that it is being addressed. Um so instead of um taking you know the word we we want to make sure however at the end of the day that the OE uh the department of education is there to be able to to assist us with this type of oversight.
▶ 1:34:46Um we also need a functional office of civil rights when safety is breached. We know that AI algorithms reflect the data that they've been trained on and as we've already seen with things like AI generated student behavior plans, racism is embedded in the algorithms. In the past, students who experienced discrimination could reach out to the OCR. But this administration has closed seven of its regional offices, including the one in Pennsylvania. And 90% of the discrimination cases OCR resolved in 2025 were simply dismissed.
▶ 1:35:14So, we can't encourage schools to procure AI tech before there are real policies and safeguards and guardrails in place to ensure that it's used responsibly. And we can start by passing the AI civil rights act and eliminated bias acts. We have to ensure that technological progress doesn't come at the cost of the communities that this administration is working really hard to leave behind.
▶ 1:35:34So while we can all uh talk about the exciting prospects that come from AI, it's irresponsible for us to not also think about the harms, think about how it could exacerbate already existing biases or problems, and as a Congress, we have a responsibility uh to address those things. Thank you. I yield back.
▶ 1:35:53Representative Owens of Utah is Thank you, Mr. Chair. Uh the usage of AI steady increases throughout our country. Uh there are different ways of doing so from schools to work to recreation to rec uh to creative purposes. In any case, it's imperative AI is being used responsibly and for the maximum potential of good. I'm glad that we're addressing this and how our teachers and schools can safely adapt and unleash the full potential of this developing technology. And I thank all my witnesses, our witnesses for being here to do this today.
▶ 1:36:24Uh Mr. Knox, uh we often hear about how AI streamlines uh [clears throat] streamlines the uh teachers administrative work such as writing emails. Uh but you also pointed out that AI is increasingly used for lesson planning and curriculum development. How good are these platforms at at doing the work? Also, to what extent and can AI generate plans that match the state's academic
▶ 1:36:48I thank you for the question. Um I think that they are more and more I I can't speak for all the products and tools that are out there but I know that the the tools that we provide in our again closed system especially um specific tools like um reading coach right now they all align based on teachers input to state standards.
▶ 1:37:08Okay. And you also mentioned in written testimony that you uh AI has been used especially helpful for literacy teachers which uh we have fallen very very much behind. to what extent uh do you and your partners been able to measure real learning uh gains or these potential uh hypothetical maybe subjective?
▶ 1:37:27Right. Um first off again I really believe and it's in the testimony or the written testimony there needs to be more research done. Um we're willing to be a participant and engage and lean in to make sure that that research um is as neutral and productive as possible. I do think that we're seeing some great use cases where teachers are seeing the gains. Um, sort of like my colleague here from Teach for America, but I I have one in particular, a special education teacher who's in Witchah, Kansas.
▶ 1:37:58He um has found to use AI tools in a way to connect his special education students, his classroom more with the parents. So, they have what's called um the words of the week. at the beginning of the school year only that his students were six of them were only speaking about or reading four words per minute.
▶ 1:38:18Today they're reading 40 words a minute and he believes it's because of this new partnership with the parents so they can continue the reading at home and it's more real time like which words are they getting better at. So he is seeing the gains he's quantifying the gains but again that's like a use case in Witchah Kansas we got to do more of that. U and also thanks for bringing those te the parents into the the mix. It's so important that we do that.
▶ 1:38:40As mentioned before, Superintendent Black, uh we all believe that AI has potential uh great potential in education, but sometimes difficult to tell how well that potential has been realized. On average, do you think teachers in this in your state are taking full advantage of AI or if not, what are the areas for
▶ 1:38:58I think we are definitely still have a lot to learn about AI as these tools develop. We've spent a lot of our time with our teachers on our various um resources and platforms that we have with our Microsoft contract. As we think about our lesson plans, I think that's the area where the majority of our um teachers have seen the benefit of that. We recently adopted um the science of reading and and passed some legislation on the third grade success act.
▶ 1:39:24And one of the things we found out was that the adopted curriculums many of our counties had did not have good phonics lessons. that was a piece that was missing. And so our teachers were able to use um AI to quickly develop a multiple list of activities and things to embed those phonics lessons into their instruction.
▶ 1:39:42Very good. Thank you so much, Mr. Sony. Uh we both agree that AI cannot replace our teachers. A state needs to be a tool to help our students develop their thinking. uh is there any additional examples of how teachers are currently employing AI to improve the students learning process without simply giving them the correct answers?
▶ 1:40:01Absolutely. So um one you know one example I'll point to I think a question that often comes up is around special education. How do we support all students with using AI tools to help their learning? And what we found is educators have the opportunity, if used correctly, to scaffold lesson plans and scaffold their lessons and the the actual materials that students are engaging with in a way that all students can engage with.
▶ 1:40:26So there's several examples whether it's use in math, use in phonics as I mentioned earlier or in special education. And I think there's immense potential and opportunity again if educators are supported, trained to understand when to use it to drive critical thinking, to make sure students are doing the heavy lifting with their learning uh and when not to use it so that students aren't taking shortcuts in in their learning journey.
▶ 1:40:49Thank you. I just how excited I am to see uh you guys on the leading edge with this not only for the our students but for the teachers and the parents and that's the combination that makes it work. So thank you guys what you're doing. I really appreciate it. I back
▶ 1:41:01Mr. Mr. Mesmer of Indiana is recognized.
▶ 1:41:04Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to the witnesses for being here today. Mr. Sahony, you mentioned that teacher voices are often missing ingredients in AI policy and product design. How do you think teachers can help shape AI development and policy?
▶ 1:41:17So, at Teacher for America, we have something called the EdTE Fellowship where we have some of our teachers who work with technology companies to actually shape how the technology gets used in the classroom. our teachers share. They're able to go deeper and better understand what the technology is to help inform and influence uh how that technology gets used in the classroom. And we also hear from the technology companies that they are able to strengthen their tools as well.
▶ 1:41:44So, it's our belief that educators, especially this next generation coming into the teaching profession, many of whom are digital natives with AI technology, have a lot to offer in terms of how the technology can be used and also how it shouldn't be used in the classroom.
▶ 1:41:58Okay. uh what issues might get overlooked without the perspective of
▶ 1:42:02There's several issues that get overlooked. First is the idea of what are what a strong teaching pedigogy look like. How is the AI tool actually supporting what we know makes for an effective teacher in the classroom. We also know how students learn and a big part of how students learn is by by engaging in building relationships with their teachers. And so making sure that the technology is used to actually personalize learning and also creating space and room for teachers to be able to continue to build those relationships.
▶ 1:42:33There's risk we lose that and the technology replaces uh in theory uh what a teacher is supposed to do. I think screen time has come up here. We don't actually again believe that AI will replace teachers but too often students spend too much time in front of screens or in front of technology. I think the real opportunity here is alongside what the technology can offer also making sure students are developing the durable skills like critical thinking, teamwork, and collaboration that many employers are going to be looking for in the future as a part of how they learn.
▶ 1:43:03Thank you. Uh Mrs. Knox, you mentioned in your written testimony that one in three teachers lacks confidence in using AI safely and effectively. Uh you mentioned Microsoft does teacher professional development through Microsoft Elevate for Educators. What do these resources look like and how can they help teachers feel more
▶ 1:43:21There's no question there's a relationship between feeling confident and then wanting to use the tools more and then using the tools even more creatively. So um we have found through elevate the best way to go about ensuring this sort of great flywheel of learning for teachers is to broker partnerships with huge organizations like the American Federation of Teachers but also with other groups like the American Association of Community Colleges um even rural groups um you know that touch teachers
▶ 1:43:51in different ways like future farmers of America and then parent groups which is like more like far 4 for and we developed these partnerships so that we're making sure that our programs and certifications are real and grounded in what students are facing today. And so our Microsoft Elevate program really does work alongside of our teachers and puts teachers voice first.
▶ 1:44:14Okay, thank you for your questions and I yield back the remainder of my time.
▶ 1:44:18Representative Thompson of Pennsylvania is recognized.
▶ 1:44:20Chairman, thank you so much. Thanks to all the witnesses for uh the information that you brought on this important topic. Mrs. Uh, Knox, you can you explain upon how Microsoft is helping special education teachers utilize utilize AI to better support students who are learning with disabilities?
▶ 1:44:38Absolutely. And thanks for the question. I um there's there just no question in my mind that um the students with disabilities um their needs are better met because of certain AI products. um in part because the company is committed to AI and accessibility in any product we develop from ground level up.
▶ 1:45:00So in addition to what we do in the school district sort of closed system um I think all of us might realize that individual products like even Microsoft Word or PowerPoint you can go in just to give you an example and I've talked to teachers about how much they love this particular aspect of our tools. you can go and go to something called immersive reader. So if you can't see well, you can make the font bigger. If you c have a hard time breaking down a lot of text, it can simplify the concepts.
▶ 1:45:30If you want to interact with the text of a document, it allows you to do that as well. So, divergent thinkers, um students who have, you know, challenges with attention, um all of these um things that they bring to the tool, they can redesign the tool and redesign the text so that they can learn more. And let me just tell you that it does two things.
▶ 1:45:52One, yes, of course, we believe that students are learning more, the students with disabilities, but it's also asking the student to think about how do I learn? How do I think? And that skill is a skill they're going to need for the rest of our lives. Just to close out on special education, there's no question it's helping with building more effective IEPs. There's no question that again I AI is helping more special education students connect better with their teachers and parents.
▶ 1:46:19And then finally, we do have a new certification that's being offered to special education teachers so they can get trained and certified and get a badge. And we did that in partnership with teachers in Witchah, Kansas.
▶ 1:46:31Very good. The evolution of this technology is perfect timing given the fact that we are way overdue of reauthorizing individuals with disabilities education act. So uh Mr. Knox, you mentioned how Microsoft worked with FFA and agriculture science teachers to develop farm beats for students using AI to bring precision agriculture and egg education directly into the classroom. Can you share early outcomes or success stories from the classrooms using farm beats for students? Yes.
▶ 1:46:59And I'm really excited that you asked the question because there's a group of students in Meckllinmberg High School um in rural Virginia um who is they're watching this uh hearing and I wanted to make sure that they and their teachers Britney Perkins Kazzy um are shouted out because the this group of students and this teacher is indicative of how we've deployed something called Farm Beats for students and there's one at least in every single state of the country.
▶ 1:47:26But let me just tell you about what they're doing in this classroom and it's just indicative of the whole process which is one um all students in agriculture science they have to learn about um plants and how well plants are doing. Um and so usually what they used to do is use a old fashioned thermometer and put it in the plant soil and then process the data that way. Well, now we give them through these kits and it was in developed with teachers.
▶ 1:47:52Um, these are sensors and the sensors go into a micro:bit and the micro:bit generates data and then we [clears throat] can manipulate data. But in addition to that, the students are also creating AI models and when they create the AI model, they can actually take pictures of the plants and determine their deficiencies and the model that this individual student has created um can predict and recommend fertilizers.
▶ 1:48:16What this does is allow the students and the teacher to understand what is precision agriculture, how is it coming into our community and it also asked them to ask you know ask questions about AI so they become AI literate. When I asked this teacher um to talk to me and she she shared openly and talked to students in her classroom if she believed in her town or in her county those students would have a chance to become more AI literate without this kind of experience. She said absolutely
▶ 1:48:47Yeah. Well, you can let them know that the chairman of the US House Committee on Agriculture is very proud of them. They're they're
▶ 1:48:54they might have heard themselves.
▶ 1:48:56They're plowing new ground here and I love it. Another resource I just want to throw out. I mean, I gotta brag a little bit about my alma mater. They uh uh um is a a something called Tilva Tilva. It's it's a Penn State Extension AI assistant for science-based a questions.
▶ 1:49:15Uh it is Pennsylvania specific, but Penn State has made a commitment to work with any other state or the District of Columbia, whomever, you know, to help uh help those entities develop this this same product. So, thank you so much.
▶ 1:49:29Well, to Ms. Perkins, I think you said it was uh the teachers who the class.
▶ 1:49:35Uh to Miss Perkins and her students, uh keep up the fantastic work and uh thanks
▶ 1:49:40Perkins Kazies.
▶ 1:49:41Perkins Kazies. Okay.
▶ 1:49:42Uh and now I yield to the ranking member for a closing statement.
▶ 1:49:46Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to the witnesses. It truly has been an informative hearing. I speak with teachers a lot um as a member of this committee and there's a lot on their plate right now. um they're they're dealing with um you know their own juggling lessons plans but also an increase in social media addiction and you know we're seeing what's happening with devices and taking them out of the classroom um and the responsibilities they have with an increase in behavioral health needs for students. there's just a lot on their plate.
▶ 1:50:16But I know that they're working to do what they can to provide a high quality education for the next generation of students and oftentimes they're trying to do all this with uh inadequate resources and insufficient pay. So at the same time, we know as we talked about today, AI is being used in more schools across the country. And as we discussed, this technology can provide teachers with new options to manage those responsibilities. But it also adds the monumental task of teaching students how to responsibly use AI in an increasingly technologydriven world.
▶ 1:50:47And educators should not have to do this alone. Uh Congress must continue to support the resources, the training, professional development necessary for teachers to do this work. Um and I just want to mention that title two of the bipartisan Every Student Succeeds Act is about funding professional development. I know many of us are former state legislators and they don't always have enough resources to fill those gaps. It's an important investment we should be uh supporting.
▶ 1:51:12Um and of course my comprehensive framework that I mentioned, this is going to provide evidence-based professional development resources to help educators understand and navigate the opportunities and risks. I hope we can work on this on a bipartisan basis. And right now, again, the Trump administration's attempt to dismantle the Department of Education isn't helping. Eliminating the Office of Education Technology doesn't help. It leaves schools and teachers without resources and guidance that they that would help them do their jobs.
▶ 1:51:41So, we cannot repeat history by allowing AI to widen existing inequities. And I hope, Mr. Chairman, that we can work together on policies and and investments that do result in every student having access to well-rounded education that will lead to their success in classrooms today and careers in the future. Uh, I I really appreciate the FFA story, Miss Knox. you told me that earlier and it's very inspirational. Um, but we want every teacher to be able to have the support and professional development they need to happen. And finally, Mr.
▶ 1:52:09Chairman, I I just want to add into the record. Um, there there were some voices that were not included here today. And I mentioned the the current um cover story on Time magazine that just came out a couple of days ago called The People Versus AI. And and just a couple excerpts and I'll enter this into the record. Not much unites Americans these days, but a growing cross-section of the public from mega loyalists to democratic socialists, pastors to policy makers, nurses to filmmakers agree that at least on on at least one thing.
▶ 1:52:38AI is moving too fast. A 2025 Pew poll found that five times as many Americans are are concerned as excited about the increased use of AI in daily life. The public thinks AI will weaken our ability to think creatively, form meaningful relationships, and make difficult decisions. Other surveys show that Americans believe AI will spread misinformation, erode our sense of purpose and meaning, and harm our social and emotional intelligence.
▶ 1:53:07So, I want to enter that into the record, Mr. Chairman, because I know we all have constituents believe that, and I think it's important to have that as part of the consideration as we talk about the challenges and opportunities going forward. and I thank you again for your testimony and I yield back the balance of my time.
▶ 1:53:22Uh well, thank you very much to all of our witnesses. Truly uh very useful insights. I think this was a uh a truly excellent panel uh and uh and a really uh important hearing. You know, I am an optimist uh when it comes to AI and education. I think there's extraordinary opportunity and potential.
▶ 1:53:40Uh but I also recognize that in order to unlock that potential, we need to address the very legitimate concerns uh and risks when it comes to privacy, the use of data, uh when it comes to uh the effect on critical thinking, when it comes to the effect that interacting with human seeming but nonhuman uh entities has on developing minds and and ultimately it requires you know building trust uh among parents and students and teachers and and school leaders and
▶ 1:54:10everyone uh that's affected. And so I think this prof professional development uh piece of it is extremely important and I think there's probably more of a role that we can play here and trying to expand access to highquality uh up-to-date professional development. Of course that's very challenging because you know you could take the world's leading expert in AI right now and they could give a presentation today and it would be outdated by next week.
▶ 1:54:32things are just moving at such a a dizzying pace and you know just for example in the last couple months uh agentic AI has suddenly gotten kind of good and and useful where you know it's probably not that far beyond today's technology where a teacher could say okay oneshot prompt I want you to grade all these papers with individualized feedback for students design tomorrow's lessons plans that incorporate all of these standards uh produce all of the accompanying worksheets collateral and assessments in a way that's tailored and scaffolded to the academic history of each student, then
▶ 1:55:03go away for an hour, come back, and it's all done. I mean, we're really not that far off from that, and it's going to continue to change and improve. But what's not what the constant is, as has been emphasized by all of our witnesses, is the, uh, foundational importance of the human element of that teacher student interaction. And so, uh, I think that, you know, we need to think about how we can continue to steer the use of these ever more powerful tools towards, uh, enhancing that and supporting that. And then, you know, finally, I think that um we discussed this issue of screen time.
▶ 1:55:33I think that you're also likely to see um the way that most people interact inside a class or out with the AI change in the in the coming years uh where the uh chatbot interface will no longer be dominant. Uh where screens might not even be the uh the dominant modality uh or interface. And I think that's going to open up some really exciting opportunities as well. Uh but also there will be challenges that come with that.
▶ 1:55:54So, there's going to be a lot to navigate and um I think that uh we're going to continue to do everything we can on on this subcommittee uh to try to stay up to speed and support the teachers and school leaders and uh and everyone that's managing this across the country uh in the months and years to come. So, thank you again to all of our witnesses. There being no other further business, the subcommittee stands adjourned.