Subcommittee Markup of Three Pieces of Legislation

Environmental Permitting and Water InfrastructureHouse Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Environment · 2026-05-14 · 119th Congress
The House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Environment met to mark up three bills: H.R. Begins at 0:14:55
Transcript
Highlights

Title

Subcommittee marks up Brownfields, recycling, and composting bills

Purpose

The House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Environment met to mark up three bills: H.R. 8739, the Brownfields Revitalization for a Better Tomorrow Act; H.R. 2145, the Recycling Infrastructure and Accessibility Act; and H.R. 4109, the Recycling and Composting Accountability Act (considered as an amendment to H.R. 2145). Debate centered on bipartisan program reforms in all three bills but sharp disagreement over reduced Brownfields authorization levels. Begins at0:14:55

Who spoke

Chairman Gary Palmer (R-AL), Subcommittee Chair0:14:55: Opened by outlining the three bills, describing Brownfields reforms such as increased grant awards, a small-community cost-share waiver, and use of funds on former military installations0:15:500:16:15; later stated the bill reflects current appropriations rather than a funding cut0:50:16.

Rep. Paul Tonko (D-NY), Subcommittee Ranking Member0:18:56: Supported the two recycling bills0:19:19 but objected that H.R. 8739 cuts Brownfields authorization from $200 million to a lower figure and the state response program from $50 million to $46.25 million0:21:380:22:08, noting every hearing witness sought more funding, not less0:22:27.

Chairman Brett Guthrie (R-KY), Full Committee Chair0:22:53: Called H.R. 8739 a negotiated compromise reflecting current appropriations since authorization lapsed in 20230:23:230:23:53; argued the bill does not cut actual spending, only aligns authorization with the ~$170 million already being spent0:39:200:39:51.

Rep. Frank Pallone (D-NJ), Full Committee Ranking Member0:25:43: Said this is the first partisan Brownfields markup in the program's history0:25:43; cited over 42,000 sites revitalized and $44 billion leveraged nationally0:41:05, and argued the committee shouldn't defer to appropriators on authorization levels0:40:44.

Rep. Nanette Barragán (D-CA)0:29:55: Cited a $1.8 million Brownfields cleanup in Carson, California at the former Fletcher Oil and Refining site feeding the Pure Water Southern California project0:31:17; also noted Brownfields projects in Maysville, Kentucky and Ranson, West Virginia0:32:12.

Rep. from Georgia0:33:06: Spoke in favor of H.R. 8739, citing nearly 450,000 remaining brownfield sites nationally and a new biannual Inspector General audit requirement0:33:590:34:22.

Rep. Raul Ruiz (D-CA)0:35:14: Said his district's 14 brownfield sites received over $581,000 in EPA funding, and nationally every dollar leverages more than $42 billion in cleanup and 220,000 jobs0:35:460:36:14; criticized the $75 million cut just 10 weeks after a $200 million draft0:37:38.

Rep. from New Jersey0:44:53: Quoted Elizabeth, NJ Mayor Bollwage calling Brownfields a "community game-changer" whose grant applications are underfunded0:45:43; criticized Republican funding priorities elsewhere, including ICE enforcement funding0:46:12.

Rep. Darren Soto (D-FL)0:48:08: Described Central Florida brownfields tied to WWII-era military training sites now redeveloped0:48:37; called the $75 million cut problematic against a proposed $250 million increase0:49:21.

Rep. Mariannette Miller-Meeks (R-IA), sponsor of H.R. 21450:51:14: Said over 36% of Iowa households (450,000 families) lack recycling access0:51:41, and Iowa captures under half its aluminum cans and only 15% of steel cans despite 90% of U.S. steel/aluminum coming from recycled material0:52:060:52:30.

Rep. Troy Carter (D-LA)0:53:43: Said Louisiana and the Gulf Coast rank among the best regions nationally for recycling end markets per a Recycling Partnership study, but lack collection infrastructure to reach them0:54:090:54:35.

Rep. Joe Evans (D-CO)0:55:50: Offered amendment RIAA_01 directing EPA to coordinate with state, local, and tribal governments on recycling/composting data and a national materials-recovery-facility inventory every four years0:56:140:56:44; noted Colorado recycled just 15% of municipal waste in 20240:57:25.

Key moments

Tonko said H.R. 8739 cuts Brownfields authorization from $200 million to a lower level and the state response program from $50 million to $46.25 million, below both the Senate's bipartisan bill and the majority's own March discussion draft0:21:380:22:08.

Ruiz noted the same committee considered a $200 million Brownfields draft on March 4th, only to vote on a version cutting the program by over $75 million ten weeks later0:37:380:37:53.

Guthrie and Pallone directly disagreed on method: Guthrie said the bill matches authorization to current appropriations of about $170 million and is not a spending cut0:39:51; Pallone said the committee should not defer to appropriators and should set authorization based on need0:40:44.

Pallone said every federal dollar invested in Brownfields returns roughly $20 in economic development0:42:50.

Barragán contrasted the proposed cut with other spending, alleging Republicans found $1.5 trillion for defense but "can't find $75 million" for rural Brownfields funding, referencing the "Investing in Rural America Act"0:37:53/0:30:49.

Palmer closed debate on H.R. 8739 stating "there are no cuts in spending," only alignment of authorization to appropriated levels0:50:16.

H.R. 8739 passed by voice vote and was forwarded to the full committee0:50:45.

Miller-Meeks said over 36% of Iowa households (450,000 families) lack recycling access, framing RIAA as both an economic and national-security measure amid competition from China for scrap materials0:51:410:52:06.

Evans's amendment to H.R. 2145, adding EPA data-collection and a four-year materials-recovery-facility inventory to harmonize with the Senate's passed Stewart Act, was adopted by voice vote0:58:21.

H.R. 2145, as amended, passed by voice vote and was forwarded to the full committee, concluding the markup0:58:210:58:58.

Metadata

CommitteeHouse Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Environment
Chamber / CongressHouse · 119th Congress
Date2026-05-14
TypeMarkup
Witnesses
(none listed in event metadata)
Videoyoutube
Transcript106 caption blocks · 6,630 words · 0:59:07 runtime
EventCongress.gov 119291