Hearings to examine the expected nomination of Sean Duffy, of Wisconsin, to be Secretary of Transportation

Aviation Safety and FAA OversightSenate Commerce, Science, and Transportation · January 15, 2025 · 119th Congress
The Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee convened this confirmation hearing to consider President Trump's nomination of former Wisconsin Congressman Sean Duffy to serve as Secretary of Transportation. Begins at ▶ 0:15:47
Transcript
Highlights

Title

Sean Duffy's Senate confirmation hearing for Transportation Secretary

Purpose

The Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee convened this confirmation hearing to consider President Trump's nomination of former Wisconsin Congressman Sean Duffy to serve as Secretary of Transportation. Following opening remarks from Chair Ted Cruz and Ranking Member Maria Cantwell, and introductions from Wisconsin Senators Ron Johnson and Tammy Baldwin, Duffy testified and answered wide-ranging questions on aviation safety, infrastructure funding, Boeing oversight, rural transportation, autonomous vehicles, and numerous state-specific projects. Begins at▶ 0:15:47

Who spoke

• Chair Ted Cruz (R-TX)▶ 0:15:47: Opened the hearing, praised bipartisan work with Cantwell, and introduced Duffy's nomination▶ 0:17:57; later questioned Duffy on Texas's environmental review authority▶ 0:42:21, deepwater port licensing delays▶ 0:43:40, high-speed rail funding transparency▶ 0:45:01, SpaceX FAA fines▶ 2:56:44, and pipeline safety regulation▶ 2:58:42.

• Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-WA), Ranking Member▶ 0:20:24: Welcomed new members, cited FAA reform and infrastructure accomplishments▶ 0:20:58, and questioned Duffy on the Jones Act▶ 0:45:57, megaproject support regardless of state size▶ 0:46:40, FAA whistleblower oversight and safety management systems at manufacturers▶ 0:47:27, public transit investment▶ 0:50:24, and later pressed on Project 2025 rulemaking priorities and document transparency▶ 3:00:09.

• Mr. Sean Duffy, nominee for Secretary of Transportation▶ 0:33:27: Introduced his family, described his priorities as improving safety and building "big, durable projects"▶ 0:36:53, cited 40,000 annual traffic deaths and his wife's survival of a head-on crash▶ 0:37:23, and committed throughout to working with Boeing on safety▶ 0:40:21, following the law on fuel economy standards▶ 2:11:05 and the two-crew rail requirement▶ 2:12:40, and reviewing numerous state and program-specific issues.

• Sen. Ron Johnson (R-WI)▶ 0:26:41: Introduced Duffy, describing his family, his daughter Valentina's Down syndrome diagnosis and open-heart surgery▶ 0:27:40, and his bipartisan Great Lakes and icebreaker work▶ 0:28:24.

• Sen. Tammy Baldwin (D-WI)▶ 1:09:58: Pressed Duffy on Buy America rules and a just-finalized DOT rule discontinuing a 40-year highway waiver▶ 1:10:24, accessibility standards for airplanes▶ 1:13:00, and traffic safety funding named for Sarah Langenkamp▶ 1:14:30.

• Sen. Deb Fischer (R-NE)▶ 0:51:43: Argued EVs are 30% heavier and cause more road wear but don't pay into the Highway Trust Fund▶ 0:52:18, and raised delays in updating female crash test dummies▶ 0:56:23.

• Sen. Brian Schatz (D-HI)▶ 0:57:30: Sought assurance IIJA funds would be released without political bias▶ 0:59:00, raised tribal transportation funding where 60% of ~150,000 tribal road miles are unpaved▶ 0:59:29, and urged treating pedestrian/cyclist/transit safety as non-zero-sum▶ 1:02:15.

• Sen. Jerry Moran (R-KS)▶ 1:04:03: Highlighted Boeing supplier Spirit AeroSystems in Kansas▶ 1:04:32, the Federal Contract Tower Program▶ 1:06:43, the Southwest Chief Amtrak route▶ 1:07:22, and short line rail tax credit provisions▶ 1:09:13.

• Sen. Dan Sullivan (R-AK)▶ 1:15:54: Described Alaska's infrastructure gaps despite being 120 times bigger than Connecticut▶ 1:16:53, secured Duffy's commitment to visit Alaska▶ 1:17:48, raised Essential Air Service for 251 roadless communities▶ 1:18:21, the Alaska Safety Initiative's $25 million annual authorization▶ 1:20:20, and NEPA permitting delays including a 40-year EIS for the Cooper Landing Bypass▶ 1:21:12.

• Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-MN)▶ 1:22:45: Discussed the Stillwater Bridge project▶ 1:22:45, Duluth's air traffic control tower▶ 1:24:12, distracted driving deaths (nine Americans killed daily)▶ 1:25:03, the Borealis Amtrak line's ridership▶ 1:26:01, recreational trails funding▶ 1:26:21, and blocked rail crossings▶ 1:27:28.

• Sen. Marsha Blackburn (R-TN)▶ 1:28:25: Raised concerns about Chinese automakers partnering with Mexico to enter the U.S. market and collect sensitive data▶ 1:28:54, pushed to raise the pilot retirement age▶ 1:30:05, and asked about I-40 rebuilding after Hurricane Helene▶ 1:32:49.

• Sen. Andy Kim (D-NJ)▶ 1:34:05: Pressed for continued funding of the Gateway Tunnel Project▶ 1:34:36, NJ Transit delays▶ 1:35:51, Amtrak funding▶ 1:36:50, and drone activity over New Jersey▶ 1:37:47.

• Sen. Ted Budd (R-NC)▶ 1:39:33: Discussed Hurricane Helene road damage in western North Carolina▶ 1:39:33, supersonic flight competition with China▶ 1:41:41, overdue FAA drone rulemaking▶ 1:42:34, and pilot testing delays▶ 1:43:50.

• Sen. Gary Peters (D-MI)▶ 1:44:37: Asked Duffy to support the U.S. auto industry against Chinese competition, covering both gas and electric vehicles▶ 1:45:02.

• Sen. Ed Markey (D-MA)▶ 1:46:22 (labeled inconsistently as "Sen. Markey" for both Michigan- and Massachusetts-related exchanges in the transcript): Raised the 70-year-old Line 5 pipeline under the Straits of Mackinac▶ 1:46:44, Great Lakes port funding disparities (as little as 2% of funds)▶ 1:47:55, and Essential Air Service for Michigan▶ 1:49:30; a later speaker labeled "Sen. Markey" also discussed auto safety, NHTSA's Tesla investigation▶ 2:08:33, fuel economy standards▶ 2:10:14, and two-person train crews▶ 2:11:39.

• Sen. John Curtis (R-UT)▶ 1:50:28: Praised Duffy's family, discussed Utah's rapid growth and need for federal support on the Salt Lake City–Provo–Ogden rail corridor's single-track bottleneck▶ 1:54:18, and interstate expansion costs▶ 1:55:33.

• Sen. Ben Ray Luján (D-NM)▶ 1:56:15: Shared his own experience surviving a drunk-driving crash▶ 1:56:43, discussed his HALT Act on drunk and distracted driving rulemaking▶ 1:57:38, cited $167 billion in 2019 economic costs from alcohol/distracted crashes▶ 1:59:01, and sought a six-month rulemaking status update commitment▶ 1:59:30.

• Sen. Bernie Moreno (R-OH)▶ 2:02:44: Argued government should not dictate powertrain choices to automakers and criticized EV investment losses▶ 2:04:48, and thanked Duffy's family▶ 2:06:59.

• Sen. Shelley Moore Capito (R-WV)▶ 2:12:53 (introduced as taking the chair; also referenced as continuing later at▶ 2:15:19): Discussed the surface transportation authorization deadline of September 30, 2026▶ 2:13:43, the "One Federal Decision" permitting process▶ 2:15:19, highway worker safety▶ 2:16:48, and East Palestine derailment response▶ 2:17:44.

• Sen. Lisa Blunt Rochester (D-DE)▶ 2:18:51: Raised port infrastructure funding▶ 2:19:36, airport terminal funding▶ 2:21:11, rural rail access▶ 2:22:49, and Delaware State University's aviation program▶ 2:24:21.

• Sen. Roger Wicker (R-MS)▶ 2:25:05: Invited Duffy to Mississippi for the June reopening of Amtrak Gulf Coast service (Mobile to New Orleans) discontinued since Hurricane Katrina▶ 2:26:27, and to the Merchant Marine Academy at Kings Point, citing deferred infrastructure repairs there▶ 2:29:52.

• Sen. Tammy Duckworth (D-IL)▶ 2:32:44: Pushed for the ASAP Act on accessible transit stations▶ 2:33:51, timely Bipartisan Infrastructure Act implementation▶ 2:35:06, the 1,500-hour pilot rule▶ 2:35:52, and FAA oversight of Boeing following an October DOT Inspector General report▶ 2:36:41.

• Sen. Tim Sheehy (R-MT)▶ 2:37:39: A survivor of a fatal aircraft crash▶ 2:40:11, raised aircraft manufacturing consolidation and domestic competition▶ 2:38:08, opposed single-pilot cockpits▶ 2:40:11, and called for a dedicated FAA code for aerial firefighting▶ 2:41:09.

• Sen. Jacky Rosen (D-NV)▶ 2:43:00: Cited Las Vegas airport's 57 million passengers and $35 billion economic output in 2023▶ 2:43:27, I-15 congestion▶ 2:45:06, and Nevada's FAA-authorized drone test site▶ 2:47:07.

• Sen. Todd Young (R-IN)▶ 2:48:58: Raised the Ohio River Crossing project connecting Evansville, IN and Henderson, KY▶ 2:49:50, autonomous vehicle policy▶ 2:51:07, and the DRIVE Safe Act apprenticeship program for young CDL holders▶ 2:53:43.

• Sen. Eric Schmitt (R-MO)▶ 3:04:55: Criticized the Biden administration's DEI focus at DOT before a national ground stop▶ 3:05:55, and discussed FAA space launch licensing competition with China▶ 3:07:30 and EV weight impacts on infrastructure▶ 3:09:55.

Key moments

• Duffy committed to prioritizing renewal of Texas's NEPA-delegation authority from the Federal Highway Administration before its March 2025 expiration, noting Texas completes environmental assessments in under 17 months versus more than double that federally▶ 0:43:12▶ 0:43:26.

• Duffy agreed EVs "should" pay into the Highway Trust Fund when questioned by Sen. Fischer but called implementation "more challenging"▶ 0:52:49▶ 0:52:54.

• Sen. Cantwell asked directly whether Duffy would prioritize FAA whistleblower protections and mandatory safety management systems at manufacturers; Duffy called it "a missing link" requiring more work▶ 0:47:27▶ 0:49:04.

• Sen. Sullivan highlighted that Alaska has over 60 Essential Air Service airports and the highest aviation fatality rate in the country per the NTSB, securing Duffy's commitment to the $25 million Alaska Safety Initiative▶ 1:19:05▶ 1:20:20.

• Sen. Cruz confronted Duffy on Project 2025, and Duffy stated he had "never read" it and did not know a specific policy was included▶ 3:00:37.

• Sen. Markey clarified on the record that no federal fuel economy standard mandates electric vehicles, and cited a 2007 law saving consumers $26 billion in fuel costs▶ 2:09:11▶ 2:10:14; Duffy committed to following the law on setting maximum feasible fuel economy standards▶ 2:11:05.

• Sen. Duckworth cited an October DOT Inspector General report finding FAA oversight of Boeing was ineffective before the Alaska Airlines door-plug incident, and that FAA officials had requested Boeing self-inspect months earlier; Duffy committed "100%" to ensuring proper FAA oversight▶ 2:36:41▶ 2:37:13.

• Sen. Sheehy, a survivor of a fatal aircraft crash whose "pilot mate did not" survive, urged rigorous scrutiny of single-pilot cockpit proposals; Duffy agreed▶ 2:40:43▶ 2:41:09.

• Sen. Wicker announced Amtrak's twice-daily Mobile–New Orleans service, discontinued since Hurricane Katrina in 2005, would reopen in June 2025, and secured Duffy's commitment to attend▶ 2:26:27▶ 2:28:12.

• Sen. Luján cited a 33% increase in drunk-driving deaths since 2019 and $167 billion in annual economic costs, pressing for a six-month update on impaired-driving detection rulemaking, which Duffy committed to▶ 1:58:39▶ 1:59:30.

Metadata

CommitteeSenate Commerce, Science, and Transportation
Chamber / CongressSenate · 119th Congress
DateJanuary 15, 2025
TypeMeeting
Witnesses
(none listed in event metadata)
Videosenate-isvp
Transcript510 caption blocks · 20,915 words · 3:11:25 runtime
EventCongress.gov 336508