AIConfirmation hearing for Elise Stefanik as UN Ambassador

Ambassador Confirmation HearingsSenate Foreign Relations · January 21, 2025 · 119th Congress
The Senate Foreign Relations Committee met to consider the nomination of Rep. Begins at ▶ 0:18:05
Transcript
Highlights

Title

Confirmation hearing for Elise Stefanik as UN Ambassador

Purpose

The Senate Foreign Relations Committee met to consider the nomination of Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-NY) to be U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations. Sens. Shelley Moore Capito (R-WV) and Tom Cotton (R-AR) introduced the nominee, after which Chairman Risch and Ranking Member Shaheen delivered opening statements before Stefanik testified and answered questions on UN reform, funding, China's influence, antisemitism, and ongoing conflicts. Begins at▶ 0:18:05

Who spoke

• Chairman Jim Risch (R-ID)▶ 0:18:05: Opened the hearing with rules on decorum▶ 0:18:37, criticized UN dysfunction, anti-Israel bias, and Chinese/Russian influence▶ 0:21:17▶ 0:29:36, and pressed Stefanik on countering China's vote-buying at the UN▶ 0:50:02.

• Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH), Ranking Member▶ 0:19:35: Supported orderly proceedings▶ 0:19:35; in her opening statement argued the UN is a "force multiplier" for U.S. taxpayer money and warned that U.S. disengagement benefits China and Russia▶ 0:35:40; pressed Stefanik on UNFPA funding▶ 0:54:45 and accountability for Russia in Ukraine▶ 0:56:19.

• Sen. Shelley Moore Capito (R-WV)▶ 0:20:20: Introduced Stefanik, praising her national security record and moral clarity on antisemitism▶ 0:22:40.

• Sen. Tom Cotton (R-AR)▶ 0:24:19: Co-introduced Stefanik, citing her work on China policy and Israel support, and urged swift, unanimous confirmation▶ 0:24:19.

• Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-NY), nominee▶ 0:38:23: Pledged to implement an "America First, peace through strength" agenda at the UN▶ 0:38:45, committed to reviewing all UN agency funding against whether it makes America "safer, stronger, more prosperous"▶ 0:49:19, confirmed support for defunding UNRWA▶ 0:54:39, and stated she shares the view that Israel has a "biblical right" to the entire West Bank▶ 2:06:04.

• Sen. James Risch *(see Chairman above)*

• Sen. Pete Ricketts (R-NE)▶ 0:58:36: Cited the U.S.'s $18 billion annual UN contribution, more than 185 other member nations combined in 2022▶ 0:59:07, and pressed on leveraging funding to drive reform▶ 0:59:40 and countering China's 85% increase in UN staff hires between 2009–2021▶ 1:01:56.

• Sen. Chris Coons (D-DE)▶ 1:03:42: Discussed countering China's technical-organization leadership bids▶ 1:04:43 and pressed on whether a 90-day foreign aid freeze covers UNICEF, World Food Program, and Ukraine energy-grid assistance▶ 1:08:16.

• Sen. Dave McCormick (R-PA)▶ 1:09:43: Raised concerns about antisemitism tied to Pittsburgh's Tree of Life shooting▶ 1:10:32, asked how Stefanik would end UNRWA's mandate▶ 1:11:02, and asked about Chinese Communist Party influence at the UN Human Rights Council▶ 1:13:19.

• Sen. Tim Kaine (D-VA)▶ 1:15:17: Noted Pete Hegseth was the only Trump nominee who refused to meet with him▶ 1:16:39; pressed Stefanik on a past tweet claiming Democrats want "open borders and mass amnesty" and asked her to name Democratic senators holding that view▶ 1:19:32; raised Haiti policy▶ 1:18:00.

• Sen. Bill Hagerty (R-TN)▶ 1:21:55: Asked Stefanik's four-year vision for the UN mission▶ 1:22:22 and pressed on UNRWA defunding▶ 1:24:33 and WHO accountability▶ 1:26:50.

• Sen. Cory Booker (D-NJ)▶ 1:28:05: Raised the humanitarian crisis in Sudan, including reported chemical weapons use▶ 1:29:11, and asked Stefanik to commit to prioritizing Sudan▶ 1:30:02.

• Sen. John Curtis (R-UT)▶ 1:34:13: Discussed Taiwan's exclusion under UN Resolution 2758▶ 1:34:41 and his bill to rank UN agencies by importance▶ 1:37:05.

• Sen. Chris Murphy (D-CT)▶ 1:39:16: Asked Stefanik to condemn Elon Musk's gesture at a rally as resembling a Nazi salute▶ 1:40:07; Stefanik denied it was such a salute▶ 1:40:32; Murphy read reactions from white-supremacist groups celebrating the gesture▶ 1:41:32.

• Sen. Rick Scott (R-FL)▶ 1:44:43: Asked about UN Human Rights Council "Agenda Item 7," which targets only Israel, citing 17 UN resolutions against Israel in 2024 versus six against the rest of the world combined▶ 1:45:58.

• Sen. Jacky Rosen (D-NV)▶ 1:49:37: Pressed on UNIFIL's failure to prevent Hezbollah tunnel-building in Lebanon▶ 1:50:52, Syria's political transition under UN Resolution 2254▶ 1:52:47, and Chinese influence over UNESCO AI standards▶ 1:53:53.

• Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX)▶ 1:55:21: Asked about Russia policy toward Putin's territorial ambitions▶ 1:56:32 and pressed on triggering "snapback" sanctions against Iran under UN Resolution 2231▶ 1:59:05.

• Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD)▶ 2:01:06: Pressed Stefanik on Palestinian self-determination and human rights▶ 2:04:19, and asked directly whether she shares former Israeli officials' view that Israel has a "biblical right" to the entire West Bank, to which she answered "yes"▶ 2:06:04.

• Sen. Steve Daines (R-MT)▶ 2:06:53: Described visiting Hezbollah tunnels in August 2023 weeks before the October 7 attack▶ 2:07:48 and asked about curbing Iran's nuclear program▶ 2:09:18.

• Sen. John Barrasso (R-WY)▶ 2:11:57: Highlighted UN Human Rights Council "Item 7" targeting only Israel▶ 2:12:25 and asked whether China should be classified as a "developing nation" at the UN▶ 2:14:30.

• Sen. Mike Lee (R-UT)▶ 2:17:06: Noted he has introduced a bill to defund the UN▶ 2:17:32, asked Stefanik to name U.S. allies at the UN▶ 2:18:03, and questioned the relationship between the UN and the International Criminal Court▶ 2:20:13.

• Sen. Brian Schatz (D-HI)▶ 2:23:38: Discussed Pacific Island nations and countering Chinese influence▶ 2:24:01, and pressed on whether the 90-day foreign aid freeze is too long given humanitarian consequences▶ 2:27:43.

• Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX)▶ 2:29:52: Detailed Iran's nuclear breakout timeline since 2020▶ 2:30:49, cited Secretary Rubio's written testimony supporting snapback sanctions▶ 2:32:41, and discussed his LIBEL Act to allow lawsuits against international organizations supporting terrorism▶ 2:35:01.

• Sen. Tammy Duckworth (D-IL)▶ 2:36:18: Asked about retaining State Department institutional expertise▶ 2:36:34, pressed on UNIFIL and Syria's post-Assad transition▶ 2:43:31, and raised disability rights at the UN▶ 2:47:08.

• Rep. Joe Wilson (R-SC): Noted as present in the hearing room in support of Stefanik▶ 2:40:28 (did not testify).

Key moments

• Chairman Risch stated the U.S. pays 22% of the UN's regular budget and 25% of its peacekeeping budget▶ 0:29:36.

• Sen. Ricketts cited that in 2022 the U.S. contributed more to the UN than 185 other member nations combined, roughly $18 billion a year▶ 0:59:07.

• Sen. Barrasso and Sen. Scott both raised UN Human Rights Council "Agenda Item 7," which exclusively targets Israel; Scott cited 17 UN General Assembly resolutions against Israel in 2024 versus six against the entire rest of the world▶ 2:12:58.

• Sen. Ricketts noted China increased its employment of nationals at the UN by 85% between 2009 and 2021▶ 1:01:56.

• Under direct questioning from Sen. Van Hollen, Stefanik confirmed she believes Israel has a "biblical right" to the entire West Bank, a view Van Hollen said contradicts the secular Zionist founders of Israel▶ 2:05:47▶ 2:06:04.

• Sen. Murphy pressed Stefanik on Elon Musk's gesture at an inaugural event, reading messages from Proud Boys and White Lives Matter chapters celebrating it as a Nazi salute; Stefanik denied the characterization and called Musk a "visionary"▶ 1:40:07▶ 1:41:32.

• Sen. Kaine confronted Stefanik over a past tweet accusing Democrats of wanting "wide-open borders and mass amnesty," asking her to name specific senators; Stefanik declined to name any and defended the underlying rhetoric▶ 1:19:32▶ 1:19:47.

• Stefanik confirmed she voted to defund UNRWA and cited Hamas leader Sinwar's possession of a UNRWA-issued passport and a Hamas data center beneath UNRWA headquarters as justification▶ 1:26:30.

• Sen. Cruz noted Secretary Rubio's written testimony affirming it is in the U.S. national security interest to trigger the UN "snapback" mechanism on Iran sanctions; Stefanik agreed▶ 2:32:41▶ 2:33:07.

• Sen. Coons and Sen. Schatz both raised concern that a 90-day pause on foreign development assistance signed the previous day could halt UNICEF, World Food Program, and Ukraine energy-grid aid without clarified scope▶ 1:08:16▶ 2:27:43.

Metadata

Official titleHearings to examine the nominations of Elise Stefanik, of New York, to be the Representative of the United States of America to the United Nations, with the rank and status of Ambassador, and the Representative of the United States of America in the Security Council of the United Nations, and to be Representative of the United States of America to the Sessions of the General Assembly of the United Nations during her tenure of service as Representative of the United States of America to the United Nations.
CommitteeSenate Foreign Relations
Chamber / CongressSenate · 119th Congress
DateJanuary 21, 2025
TypeMeeting
Witnesses
(none listed in event metadata)
Videosenate-isvp
Transcript419 caption blocks · 20,510 words · 2:48:48 runtime
EventCongress.gov 336545