AISenate Finance Committee considers four Treasury and HHS nominees

Treasury and HHS ConfirmationsSenate Finance · 2025-07-31 · 119th Congress
The Senate Finance Committee met on July 31, 2025 to consider four nominations: Bryan Switzer for Deputy U.S. Begins at 0:38:50
Transcript
Highlights

Title

Senate Finance Committee considers four Treasury and HHS nominees

Purpose

The Senate Finance Committee met on July 31, 2025 to consider four nominations: Bryan Switzer for Deputy U.S. Trade Representative (Asia, Textiles, Investment, Services and Intellectual Property), Gustav Chiarello III for Assistant Secretary for Financial Resources at HHS, Michael Stuart for General Counsel of HHS, and Derek Theurer for Deputy Under Secretary of the Treasury. The session opened with a brief business meeting on separate previously-heard nominees (Jonathan McKernan and Dr. Alex Adams) before recessing and reconvening for opening statements and member questioning of the four nominees. Begins at0:38:50

Who spoke

Chair Mike Crapo (R-ID)0:25:17: Opened the pre-recess business meeting on McKernan and Adams nominations0:25:17, reconvened the hearing0:38:50, introduced all four nominees' backgrounds0:39:18, and posed the four standard yes/no nominee questions0:49:21; later questioned Switzer on IP enforcement0:48:14 and Stuart on 2022/2024 campaign-finance compliance1:11:49.

Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR), Ranking Member0:27:43: Praised retiring recording studio director Bob Vicar0:27:43; opposed McKernan and Adams, citing weakened oversight of treatment facilities and defunding of disability programs in Idaho0:28:400:29:09, and DOGE's access to the Treasury payment system0:30:52; in the second panel pressed Stuart repeatedly on EMTALA compliance for pregnant women, saying he "ducked" the questions0:59:21, and pressed Switzer on tariff relief for small businesses0:17:53.

Mr. Bryan Switzer, USTR nominee0:50:34: Outlined a trade agenda prioritizing reciprocity, IP protection, and supply-chain de-risking in sectors like semiconductors and pharmaceuticals0:51:360:53:07; on China IP theft, described pursuing country-wide rather than case-by-case enforcement1:10:44; named tourism as the top U.S. services export1:44:58; said the U.S. does not seek to fully decouple from China but wants "fairness, reciprocity and strategic de-risking"1:24:23.

Mr. Gustav Chiarello III, HHS Assistant Secretary nominee0:54:35: Said HHS spent $1.7 trillion in FY2024, the highest of any federal agency, while its budget grew nearly 40% and staffing 17% under the Biden administration without improving health outcomes0:56:260:56:56; committed to reviewing canceled CDC contracts and reporting back to the committee2:10:062:10:28; declined to directly answer whether preventive spending saves money long-term, instead citing balancing incentives against waste, fraud and abuse1:11:11.

Mr. Michael Stuart, HHS General Counsel nominee0:59:20: Described his record prosecuting Medicaid fraud and opioid cases as West Virginia U.S. Attorney1:01:42; repeatedly said his role is to "follow the law" rather than create policy1:34:29; declined to give a direct yes/no on whether Secretary Kennedy could cancel a grant for an arbitrary reason under 42 USC 300-55, saying he'd need to review contract terms1:56:29; said nothing in EMTALA "prevents emergency treatment for pregnant women"1:15:30.

Mr. Derek Theurer, Treasury Deputy Under Secretary nominee1:04:38: Cited prior roles under Sen. Cassidy, Rep. Jason Smith, and Speaker Mike Johnson1:05:34; committed to keeping Congress informed on Treasury's implementation of the "One Big Beautiful Bill," including wind/solar tax credit phase-out guidance1:20:03; said CDFI Fund allocation questions were outside his current responsibilities1:54:48.

Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-IA)1:19:02: Pressed Theurer to commit to consulting Congress on regulations implementing the new tax law1:19:48, particularly on the wind/solar credit phase-out "beginning of construction" definition1:20:56 and clean fuel production credit guidance timeline1:22:43.

Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)1:27:45: Raised carbon-pollution trade disadvantages versus China with Switzer1:27:45; criticized HHS for a persistent ~20% Medicare payment disparity between Rhode Island and neighboring Connecticut/Massachusetts hospitals, calling it "indefensible"1:29:55.

Sen. James Lankford (R-OK)1:31:33: Asked Stuart whether he would ensure the administration follows the law where the Biden administration allegedly did not, citing Title X and conscience-protection disputes in Oklahoma1:32:051:33:19; criticized HHS grant-decision "insider" patterns and cited a $350,000 "AI smart toilet" grant as wasteful spending1:35:581:36:25.

Sen. Maggie Hassan (D-NH)1:37:44: Asked all nominees whether they would follow the law over a presidential directive to break it1:38:13; pressed Stuart on methadone/medication-assisted treatment access1:39:40; asked Chiarello to commit to fully distributing $286 million in appropriated Title X funding, noting $500,000 withheld from New Hampshire1:41:251:42:26; criticized tariffs on Canada as damaging to New Hampshire1:42:57.

Sen. Todd Young (R-IN)2:01:14: Asked Switzer how he would use trade tools to address foreign drug-pricing practices that shift R&D costs to U.S. consumers, including China's national drug list requiring an initial 80% price discount2:02:042:03:50.

Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto (D-NV)1:44:31: Noted travel/tourism is the top U.S. service export, contributing $2.9 trillion and 15 million jobs1:45:34; pressed Switzer on tariff harm to Nevada's 300,000 tourism jobs1:45:50; questioned the enforceability of announced but unwritten trade deals1:47:36.

Sen. Steve Daines (R-MT)1:49:42: Praised the "big, beautiful bill" as preventing a $4.5 trillion tax increase and saving the average Montana family $3,000/year1:51:12; pressed Theurer to commit to safeguarding renewable-energy projects under existing "beginning of construction" guidance1:52:42 and to allocate remaining 2025 CDFI Fund appropriations1:54:18.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA)1:55:01: Pressed Stuart on whether Secretary Kennedy could legally cancel grants for reasons outside 42 USC 300-55's "material failure to comply" standard, using a hypothetical of canceling a grant because "I do not like her face"1:56:13; said this mirrored the actual grounds Kennedy cited in canceling projects nationwide2:00:44.

Sen. Todd Young — see above.

Sen. Todd Sweitzer (as addressed) / Sen. Thom Tillis (R-NC)2:13:46: Noted Switzer's nomination had no pronunciation "answer key"; raised concerns about Chinese IP theft underlying China's innovation and asked about the administration's posture on AI copyright disputes2:15:072:15:48; also raised counterfeit/unsafe drugs entering from India2:16:57.

Sen. Marsha Blackburn (R-TN)2:19:08: Asked Switzer to detail systematic IP protection approaches across pharma and AI health technology2:19:59; asked Stuart about applying past fraud task-force experience to Medicaid/Medicare fraud, citing up to 25% improper Medicaid payments2:23:22.

Sen. John Barrasso (R-WY)2:25:27: Asked Chiarello how he would ensure states can efficiently access the $500 million-per-state Rural Health Transformation Program2:25:59; asked Switzer to commit to countering Chinese circumvention of the 2024 Russian uranium import ban, citing over 150,000 pounds of Russian-origin uranium reaching the U.S. via China2:28:142:28:47.

Sen. Ben Ray Luján (D-NM)2:31:41: Asked all four nominees to commit to following the law2:31:41; pressed Switzer on whether the measles vaccine is safe and effective, receiving repeated non-yes/no answers2:32:03; pressed Stuart on withheld Head Start funding in New Mexico and a GAO finding that the administration violated the law2:34:182:34:52; in closing, called Stuart's EMTALA answers "an incomprehensible set of comments... a word salad"2:39:08.

Key moments

Chiarello testified HHS spent $1.7 trillion in FY2024, the most of any federal agency, while its budget rose nearly 40% and staffing 17% over four years without improving outcomes like cancer, diabetes, or mental health rates0:56:56.

Wyden pressed Stuart three times on whether EMTALA requires emergency reproductive care without women becoming septic; Stuart repeatedly said "nothing in the law prevents emergency treatment for pregnant women" without directly answering1:14:45.

Warren used a hypothetical — "I do not like her face" — to press Stuart on whether Secretary Kennedy could cancel HHS grants outside the statutory "material failure to comply" standard under 42 USC 300-55; Stuart repeatedly avoided a direct yes/no, saying his advice would be to "follow the terms and conditions"1:56:13.

Barrasso said Russia has funneled over 150,000 pounds of enriched uranium to the U.S. via China, circumventing the 2024 Russian uranium import ban; Switzer committed to working with Congress on binding long-term solutions2:28:472:29:35.

Luján asked Switzer three times whether the measles vaccine is safe and effective; Switzer would not answer yes or no, instead saying he supports Secretary Kennedy's statement that vaccination is "the best way to protect yourself"2:32:03.

Switzer said China's National Family Planning and Health Commission demands an initial 80% discount off global drug prices before allowing sale, followed by further renegotiated cuts, calling this a discriminatory practice USTR intends to confront2:03:502:04:15.

Whitehouse said hospitals in neighboring Connecticut and Massachusetts are paid roughly 20% more than Rhode Island hospitals for identical services, calling the discrepancy "indefensible" and accusing HHS of being "too lazy and disinterested" to fix it1:29:551:30:25.

Lankford cited a $350,000 NIH grant for an AI-enabled "smart toilet" and federally funded studies on helmet effectiveness in West Africa and climate change in North Africa as examples of questionable research spending1:36:251:36:56.

Warnock pressed Chiarello on why CDC canceled multiyear contracts that were up to 90% complete, calling it "an ideological waste of federal resources"; Chiarello committed to look into the contracts and report back2:08:112:10:28.

Daines said the "big, beautiful bill" averted a $4.5 trillion tax increase and would save the average Montana family $3,000 a year, with about 90% of seniors seeing Social Security benefits untaxed1:51:121:51:44.

Metadata

Official titleHearings to examine the nominations of Bryan Switzer, of Virginia, to be a Deputy United States Trade Representative (Asia, Textiles, Investment, Services, and Intellectual Property), with the rank of Ambassador, and Gustav Chiarello III, of Virginia, to be an Assistant Secretary, and Michael Stuart, of West Virginia, to be General Counsel, both of the Department of Health and Human Services, and Derek Theurer, of Virginia, to be a Deputy Under Secretary of the Treasury, vice Jonathan Davidson.
CommitteeSenate Finance
Chamber / CongressSenate · 119th Congress
Date2025-07-31
TypeMeeting
Witnesses
(none listed in event metadata)
Videosenate-isvp
Transcript379 caption blocks · 18,137 words · 2:41:05 runtime
EventCongress.gov 337340